With respect to your frustrations with ZODL and accepting donations from right-leaning firms and organizations: I hear you, but it’s a very idealistic position that you’re taking
Yes, I agree.
(I think?) You’re relatively new to this conversation, and I know I’m talking to a lobbiest, but this movement overall was started with idealism. What I dislike especially is bending idealistic words to achieve realpolitik.
Many statements in your message don’t hold up under scrutiny.
Not everyone is in a position to reject investment based on political ideology, especially if they’re a startup
Clearly and purely false. Every person is in a position to reject investment.
It’s a kind of freedom: the freedom to say no.
Significantly, ZODL was not a startup in any way but on paper: technically true, but intentionally misleading. The personnel were identical to ECC, and the primary protocol engineers are largely the same as when Zcash began 10 years ago. This is the same paltering ( To talk insincerely; to equivocate in speech or actions) that’s been used repeatedly to justify the shift to a VC-compatible for-profit project.
What I think: the old system (ECC/Bootstrap) didn’t have enough guaranteed incoming money to satisfy workers and executives, and/or investors weren’t going to see enough returns if things were left as organized under a nonprofit maintaining a “public good.”
That’s a very different picture than the one you seek to establish by saying, ‘some people must accept money made available to them, regardless of its source.’
Investors’ beliefs are separate from the chain and those who are building on it
I think this has some nuance, but this is not totally true here. Of course, something publicly available to buy can be bought by anyone. Why and how, and for whom does it appreciate, are possibly important points. Who benefits?
People can decide to ‘build on it’ or not. Context could help inform such decisions. That’s one reason why using misleading words and making hidden decisions on overall direction is bad, in the long run, for a project the public and developers are supposed to engage with.
When the capital of investors touches each and every major development organization - as has become the overwhelmingly clear picture - they are fueling development, and the idea of separation is stretched thin, particularly when the profitable exit is asset appreciation itself.
some people might associate Zcash with right-leaning organizations, but there isn’t one representative that speaks for the entire ecosystem
I’ve gone to lengths to compile evidence that shows a pattern of the leading orgs associating with active right-wing authoritarian forces operating at high levels. I haven’t found other evidence to offset these findings either.
Of course, this wasn’t in the press releases, this was something I figured out. Some of my predictions turned out to be correct, and it is still not acknowledged, here anyway, that this is the state of affairs.
there isn’t one representative that speaks for the entire ecosystem… how decentralized it is compared to other chains where one or two organizations (typically the labs and/or foundation) are the de facto representatives). This is actually a key point of our messaging and advocacy: explaining to policymakers and other stakeholders the wide range of ecosystem stakeholders
No. This is all wrong. The ecosystem is united behind the decision-making power of ZODL and their investors, some of whom have donated to Shielded Labs, who support Tachyon and Valar, and now significantly overlap with your lobbying organization PGPZ.
There is not a decentralized decision making structure, and AFAICT I am one of the only people who has the gumption to even voice things publicly. Privately I have talked to several key people who are concerned, but they will not speak out. Why is this?
I’m still waiting for a more substantive ZODL comment from @joshs or anyone from the ZODL team (@peacemonger sometimes is raw and off the cuff?) @nuttycom perhaps? @str4d wants me to write ZIPs. @daira said I look bad for questioning authority, or, I don’t have (non-public) information, or something like that.
@ebfull and @ValarDragon representing Tachyon and Valar have not responded here. (though they did post that
we operate with full independence from [our donors], and we have no ongoing pledged financial support
on August 13 2026.)
Shielded Labs’ @aquietinvestor has been good enough to at least respond to some of these findings, and they have claimed independence. @zooko @nathan-at-least and other SL workers have not gone on record.
Anyhow you can find josh, zooko, and ValarDragon together on cypherpunk corporation’s advisory board.