Vision for January 2027

Instead of removing the consensus branch ID, I would much prefer we deploy ZIP 248 signing variants that allow users to opt out of signing over the consensus branch ID and the transaction expiry height. They give up a modicum of replay protection in doing so, but in exchange they get the ability for transactions to remain valid across network upgrade boundaries (at risk to themselves) and potential reduction in their anonymity set.

I’m fine with people being able to opt in to reducing their security in this fashion. But the the current signing algorithm, which works just fine for the vast majority of transactions, should remain the safe default.

6 Likes