A few specific questions (I am ignorant about much of it):
1. Why did known bugs reach Solana Mainnet? The December 2020 defect was already known, and the February 2024 bug had appeared on Devnet. What failed between identifying the problem and fixing it in production?
2. How do you test fork-selection logic? The September 2022 bug stopped consensus after duplicate blocks were produced. How do you reproduce these conditions in testing? What was being tested then, and what is tested now?
3. Why did bot traffic halt Solana but not Zcash? The obvious difference is throughput. Zcash’s sandblasting attack bloated the chain and hurt wallet synchronisation, but blocks continued.
NU7 reduced block intervals from 75 to 25 seconds and introduced limits on shielded activity to prevent spam. Project Tachyon aims to take throughput much further, potentially to 50,000 transactions per second.
So, looking ahead, which of Solana’s failures were inherent to operating at that scale, and which were avoidable?
4. What changed at Solana after February 2024? Which technical or procedural improvements explain Solana’s better uptime since?
5. How many people can independently review the code for each project? Auditing a Halo 2 circuit and auditing consensus code seem to me rather different problems.
Is there a meaningful way to compare their complexity, and how many qualified independent reviewers exist for each?
Could the small pool of ZK circuit specialists help explain why Orchard’s soundness vulnerability went undetected for so long?
I am interested in how much of this comes down to architecture, and how much to what each development team considers ready to ship.
Thank you,
An interested subject matter enthusiast.
P.S. I hope these technical discussions get split into their own thread, so they can be found and continued later.