Zcash Agora: one vote, one person

Hi all,

In Are Zcash users represented in today’s polling?, @emersonian lays out the numbers:

  • No official Zcash poll has ever had more than about 150 human voters. The largest was 145 ZCAP members in December 2025.
  • 57,312 wallets were connected to zec.rocks alone when he wrote.
  • In the Q3 grants round, about 2.18 million ZEC voted on every proposal. Changing most of the results would have taken 172,623 people holding 10 ZEC each, all voting the same way.

As a post quoted further down puts it: one person voting with 1,000 ZEC carries the same weight as 1,000 people voting with 1 ZEC each, and “when I hear ‘the community voted’, I’d love to know how many people were behind the result.”

Zcash Agora is one answer to that problem: it is a voting system enforcing a one person = one vote and offers a test poll on the five NU7.1 questions, running beside the coinholder poll that opened today.

Vote here until 30 November, 23:59 UTC: Zcash Agora

Code here GitHub - nikkolasg/zcash-agora: Zcash Agora: one passport, one voice. People-count polling for the Zcash ecosystem, a companion to coinholder polls. Built on isoloir. · GitHub

It is unofficial and decides nothing. It adds one number, how many people stand behind each answer, next to the count of coins.

How it works

You prove once that you hold a valid, unexpired passport, with the ZKPassport app on your phone. Any nationality, any age. What leaves the phone is a proof and a salted number unique to the document, so one passport registers once. No name, nationality, birth date or photo.

You answer the five questions on one ballot. Each answer is proved in your browser and sealed until the close. At the close the answers open under pseudonyms that nothing links to you, to your registration, or to each other.

Every registration, ballot and result sits in a public append-only log that anyone can recount; the vote page has a button that does it in your browser. The code, the protocol and its spec and the log are open.

Who do you have to trust?

drand, for secrecy until the close. Your ballot is encrypted to a future round of drand, a randomness beacon run by Cloudflare, EPFL, Kudelski and a dozen other operators, in production for more than six years and used by Filecoin among others. Nobody can open a vote before the close unless a threshold of them collude. drand does not know it is being used for a Zcash poll: the system never contacts it, it only uses its timelock encryption (paper, code).

ZKPassport, for the registration. You run their app, and the number that identifies your passport is salted with a key their service holds, so that even the issuing state cannot recognize it. If that service colluded with someone who has your passport data, they could tell that you registered. They could not tell how you voted: a ballot proves that you are registered, not which registration is yours. Their circuits are open source.

ZKPassport and the TACEO network, for the registration. You run the ZKPassport app. The number that identifies your passport is salted through an OPRF run on the TACEO network: the salting key is split 2-of-3 between independent operators, ZKPassport being one of them. The operators see only a blinded request, so they learn nothing about your passport. This is what stops even the issuing state from recognizing the number. If enough of those operators colluded with someone who has your passport data, they could tell that you registered. They could not tell how you voted: a ballot proves that you are registered, not which registration is yours.

The server that runs the poll, for almost nothing. The only thing it can do is leave a ballot out, and that is detectable: your browser keeps what it sent, and you can publish a complaint anyone can check against the log. It never sees who you are, because ballots arrive through public Nostr relays. It cannot read a ballot before the close, change one, or add its own, because every ballot and registration carries a proof anyone can re-verify. The log is timestamped in Bitcoin with OpenTimestamps (I’d be happy to move that to Zcash, but I found no free equivalent).

The issuing states, for not forging voters. A passport is valid because a state signed it, so a state can sign as many as it likes and each would count as a voter. Nationality is not revealed, so nobody could tell which state did it. What a state cannot do is learn that you registered or how you voted: the salted number hides the first (see above), and the ballot proof hides the second.

The relays, for your IP address. The relay you post to sees your IP and a sealed envelope. Use Tor or a VPN if that matters to you.

A side-by-side with the coinholder poll’s design is here.

Why passports?

I know this is not ideal: some of you will refuse to scan a passport, and many people have none. Zcash is about getting financial freedom without any state control.

But I think the status quo, having no tool that puts people at the center, is worse. Coinholder polling counts coins; nothing today counts humans.

Proving in zero knowledge that you hold a valid passport is, in my opinion, the most private and robust way to get one person = one vote that can be built today. ZKPassport is the only tool I found that does it while keeping the voter private: your passport data never leaves your phone. More than 17,000 people used it in Aztec’s token sale, it gave discounted tickets at Devconnect, and it joined Aztec Labs in May, which committed to keeping the protocol and the app open source.

It is not perfect. A passport can be lent for money, so cheating is possible, but every extra vote needs another real person. And passports are the first proof of personhood accepted on Zcash Agora, not the last. I considered Gitcoin Passport (now Human Passport), but its score is tied to a public wallet, and one person can hold several.

Two potential alternatives without passports

The forum’s trust levels already separate real members from throwaway accounts, and both of these build on that.

A TLSNotary committee. With TLSNotary, a voter proves from their browser that they are logged in here with posting rights, and publishes only a salted hash of their user id. Zcash Agora cannot be the notary, as it could mint voters. A few Zcash organizations would each run one, and a registration would count once two have signed.

A registry signed by the forum. The forum signs, once a day, the list of accounts with enough standing. A voter proves in zero knowledge that their account is in it, without saying which. It needs a small plugin, and so the forum’s admins. The risk sits with the forum: whoever holds its signing key could mint voters.

I built neither so far, because both need something from the forum’s side. If the organizations or the admins are willing to explore them, I’d be happy to help design and implement. And if you know another proof of personhood that is as hard to forge and as private, I want to hear it.

One last note. A poll could also require that the passport holder holds some ZEC, any amount, proved in zero knowledge the way the coinholder poll does it, without linking the coins to the passport. That would make the count “people who hold Zcash” rather than “people”. It should be doable, though it needs support from wallets. It is a light filter, since a few cents of ZEC pass it, and it leaves out people who hold none, so I see it as an option per poll, not a default. I’d like to hear whether people want it.

Disclosure: I work at ZODL. This is a personal project, built on my own time; ZODL has no part in it.

6 Likes