ZCG and the Dev Fund: Timeline for Proposals and Polling

There’s an R&D Discord?

Daira you approved the PR for the Orchard soundness bug from Ying Tong. You nearly killed the project.

Your quality assurance and specs clearly do not work.

Please fix your own house. Before throwing rocks at others over minor things.

3 Likes

I’m not an engineer on this project but this is the worst possible argument you could make. Even if I were to agree with your premise, and I don’t, you want the engineer who clearly knows the stakes and has shown time and again that they have learned from past experience much more than you want the as yet untouched newcomer who lacks the same somatic experience of the risk they are taking when they are not careful.

I sincerely hope you are not an engineering manager at any of these engineering groups.

4 Likes

hey there, is there a process to get proposal posts evaluated ?

This seems like a deliberate misinterpretation, I said no such thing in general. “Us” in context referred to the protocol and node developers who had not been informed, which includes both ZODL and ZF engineers, among others.

2 Likes

Nice double-bind that’s being set up here. Reply to misinformation on the Forum and it must mean I’m not working (false). Miss any of the governance discussion and I’m not keeping up-to-date with things that “everyone has agreed”.

4 Likes

I did, yes. That is 100% consistent with my long-held and publically stated position, before that point and since, that this stuff is really fucking difficult and even experts make mistakes.

10 Likes

(Not speaking on behalf of ZF, as always)

I 100% endorse Daira-Emma’s opinion, which I couldn’t possibly articulate any better.

Also, those attacks above on Daira-Emma’s competency are among the most absurd things I’ve ever read in these forums. I’m convinced that without Daira-Emma this project would have collapsed years ago. Which is a really untenable position for a project of course, but it’s the reality. (And not to downplay other engineers which also have been critical to the project.)

8 Likes

This is the kind of dismissive bullshit I demand be removed from this forum. THE RECEIPTS OF MY WORK ARE ON THIS FORUM. Your laziness and your shitty attitude is not acceptable.

3 Likes

There is; it was set up nearly six years ago as a place for async technical conversations about Zcash R&D. There’s an invite link on the ZF homepage in the “Get Involved” menu.

4 Likes

So this was significantly edited on your part, but your also just wrong.

At what point did Vizor have any move to 400 zats? You can conjure any grand story you want. Have you ever talked to the Vizor team? Shielded Labs had been campaigning for a reduction to 1000 zats for months at the time.

Whatever the reasons for NU7’s timing, and the rights and wrongs of the fee change, surely we can all agree on one thing: a protocol upgrade shouldn’t activate until its specification has been merged and checked against the implementations.

That isn’t a criticism of anyone’s work.

It’s a basic safeguard against breaking changes that would hit everyone using the network.

So far NU7 seems stable, although some partners and wallets are still catching up with the changes.

Attacks on anyone’s competence or character won’t settle any of this.

5 Likes

Hi @thowar2 the ZIP Editors’ meeting is today. Every Tuesday in fact. Meaningful work is done there.

Certainly a thoughtful network engineer who spent 14 hours a day analyzing and updating ZIPs could meaningfully improve Zcash. In fact, that meeting is largely populated by people who are in that class. Moreover many of them have worked those kinds of ours for around a decade.

Grab your oar.

3 Likes

Ive joined some meetings, they have always been open. All you have to do is ask to join, which is what I did :slight_smile:

I know.. I fully support a complete boycott of widely understood surveillance technology like discord.

It is irresponsible and brings harm to the less well-informed for privacy thinkers to use that platform.

Curious whether Users have a stake in fees?

The only line of code known to not have a bug follows:

2 Likes

@ValarDragon @Karma @thowar2 was Keplr developed against specs?

This is a serious question. Zcash has THE BEST security record of any cryptocurrency in history.

This a largely due to the specification process that e.g. @daira, @ebfull, @str4d and others designed like the professional and competent security experts they are.

5 Likes