[ZIP] Zcash Adoption Pool (ZAP)

Funding initiatives that have positive ROI is always a good idea.

I think the best place is to start with small wins.

More focus should be spent on greater DeFi adoption of zcash. There are many arbitrary opinions on what private money should be used for, the market should figure that out. But expanding access to use zcash across many different ecosystems by making it more liquid helps people use zcash without ZCG having to form strong opinions.

ZCG should focus on making zcash tradable on chain without any permissions needed and the ability to trade in and out of zcash in size with minimal fees.

Initiatives like this put ZCG in a good spot to make others on the side of the debate happier.

Hi all, my name is Savannah Sly and I am a longtime advocate for the rights and safety of people in the sex industry, both sex workers and survivors of exploitation. I’m wading into this conversation to express my deep gratitude for Violet and the education she has been bringing to sex worker communities in the US and beyond, about crypto, privacy, and online safety. I’m writing in my personal capacity, but should note that I am also on the board of Free Speech Coalition, which has thoroughly documented patterns of banking discrimination against legal adult sex workers, and it’s ramifications on people experiencing exploitation and trafficking in the sex industry. You can learn more about banking discrimination against these populations by visiting the Free Speech Coalition’s website under “advocacy” (for some reason I’m having an issue posting links on this reply I’m posting).

Violet has been invaluable to me as a source of information about crypto options for sex workers, as well as online safety. Sex workers have been at the forefront of technological advances such as the adoption of cryptocurrency, but we are often left navigating these uncharted waters on our own, regardless of our skill sets. Violet has emerged as an expert in crypto who also possesses the cultural competency to help sex workers understand how to use crypto safety, effectively, and practically. I have personally benefited from Violet’s one-on-one education, as well as her extensive safety/privacy/crypto publications on her website, which are geared specifically to the sex worker community. Violet’s offerings are rare in our community, and greatly needed.

I applaud everyone who has supported Violet and Mylo’s efforts to extend educational opportunities to sex working communities. I myself have shared word of Violet’s workshops to sex worker advocacy groups in the US, because I trust her. I am contributing to this conversation as an expert in sex workers rights and safety, and strongly recommend the sustained support of Violet’s important educational work about cryptocurrency for sex workers and other marginalized communities vulnerable debanking.

8 Likes

I oppose the ZCG program in principle. I left ZCAP in part because I felt my participation implicitly condoned ZCG’s existence.

That said, if ZCG must exist, @fabacab 's program is the best I’ve seen proposed or put into action. In particular, it focuses on the sex industry, which is probably the best product/market fit for Zcash. Adoption there is an essential step in its growth.

So conflicted, but on net positive.

7 Likes

I have made an account in order to weigh in to this conversation:

I am a sex worker and I have recently started using cryptocurrency in general and zcash in particular, almost entirely due to @fabacab 's teaching, advocacy, and general tech support and encouragement. She gave me zcash one time out of her own funds because zcash had spiked in value. She was giving it out zcash in this fashion, (I think it was $50 worth?) to every sex worker who dm’d her, I’m not sure how much she gave out. This was her own funds, not the money from the grant. I think she was doing this for 2 reasons: because she wanted to share with her community, and also because she believes very strongly that zcash is the best tool for people who are vulnerable for getting debanked such as sex workers. She wants to promote more such people to use it.

I think that giving out small amounts of zcash to individuals is really helpful in getting them to try it out for the first time. Some people in the discussion were suggesting that people be given funds and then they should send it back, and I just don’t think this is very realistic, because what normal person would be interested in trying this, or ever use it again? If you get, for example, 50 dollars worth of zcash donated to you, you can experience for the first time having a crypto wallet app on your phone, writing down the recovery phrase somewhere, using it to buy things, and generally having the experience of wow, huh, this really works.

Shortly after @fabacab got me into zcash, I got a client who liked cryptocurrency to send me $500 of zcash, which was the first time i was ever paid in something other than paper dollars for sex work. Using @fabacab 's amazing detailed guides to using zcash she hosts on her work website, I was able to try out buying things with this zcash such as a plane ticket, a few hotel rooms for work purposes, some various online purchases, and even chipotle burritos thru an app that created a qr code that chipotle can scan. I really got a kick out of buying burritos using anonymous cryptocurrency. I felt very cyberpunk or something. I also used the crosspay feature of zodl wallet to buy phone service and vpn service anonymously for the first time, and now this is what I use always. I have set up coinbase account which is way better than using the crypto atm i used at first, and I even prefer using zcash to buy things online using cards created thru bitrefil, instead of using my normal bank card, just because I do not like to be surveilled by creepy entities.

I don’t mean to get too caught up in the weeds, but I just wanted to say that I think giving out funds in the form of zcash is a good strategy in getting real people who should be using it to try it out for the first time, because the first time i used crypto, I was very nervous. I was pretty afraid I would make a careless mistake and all my money would just vanish. But since I have more experience with it now, I feel pretty confident buying zcash, moving it from wallet to wallet, using it to buy things, etc. When I hit send, I feel confident that it will go thru and not just mysteriously vanish like I used to fear.

I do not think that people gifted zcash are likely to just convert it into cash, partly because I do not even really know how to convert zcash into paper dollars and I haven’t had a need to actually, because i have alot more paper dollars usually than i have zcash. I am not really sure why this matters, but it seemed people were debating about whether people given zcash would just convert it into fiat currency.

I just want to conclude by saying I agree with what was said above that most people perceive crypto negatively, as a scam, or a strange and inexplicable thing that an annoying type of guy called a crypto bro is into. I think that giving out small amounts of funds to sex workers is not a form of charity, but it is more of an effective business promotion for zcash, because each sex worker who learns about zcash and starts accepting payment in zcash does alot to normalize zcash as a concept and get it to take off, and I think sex work is one of the most perfect example real world use cases for zcash, because it is a totally victimless crime for which anonymous forms of money are particularly useful for, for both the workers and the clients. The more we normalize using it, the closer zcash gets to really taking off and gaining widespread adoption. So in conclusion I think giving out ZEC to sex workers is a good promotion tactic to get more zcash users, and @fabacab has been a tireless promoter in this direction!

11 Likes

My response to ZAP, and to the other Development Fund proposals, is here:

The ZCG Lockbox: one tap off, the bigger one left running.

I like ZAP’s focus on adoption, but I have concerns about its eligibility test and its list of beneficiaries.

@vaspholdings Did you not consider @fabacab’s newest draft, which does not give a list of beneficiaries?

3 Likes

@fabacab, I stand corrected that the list of example beneficiaries has been removed.

2:30 am on a Saturday night, with the compressed timetable of this governance situation, isn’t my finest hour for navigating a 280-post discussion and a moving ZIP draft. Apologies, I’ll do better.

I agree with you 100% that mass adoption for P2P and other payments is a key part of Zcash’s future security. Mass adoption IS protection against political attacks on Zcash.

Despite the considerable update, I still find the ZIP’s political framing excessive. Earlier, I wrote:

Its list of example beneficiaries is a mistake. A governance ZIP should set broad, durable eligibility rules, not catalogue social and political flashpoints. Do that once, and every future funding ZIP becomes an argument over whose cause gets named.

The list has gone. But the theory of political attacks, adversaries and alignments is another way of expressing much the same thinking.

I’m not suggesting ZAP mandates funding politically aligned groups. It doesn’t. But why embed a particular theory of how regulators, payment incumbents and other adversaries calculate the cost of attacking Zcash in the rules for awarding grants?

ZIP 1015 already discusses regulatory risks, centralisation and the dangers of depending on a handful of organisations. It gives ZCG broad discretion to fund work advancing Zcash’s usability, security, privacy and adoption.

What problem with the current grant criteria requires changing them in this way?

The adoption test still seems too narrow. Wallets, cryptography, infrastructure and early community-building may not produce measurable individual ZEC use for years. That doesn’t mean they aren’t important to adoption.

I recognise that the draft doesn’t require proof that adoption has already happened. But it still favours grants expected to produce an increase in distinct shielded ZEC recipients, and gives less weight to spending that ends a disbursement chain.

Zodl’s CrossPay feature is a key example of why this distinction matters. The recipient doesn’t need to adopt Zcash for the ZEC-related payment to be useful.

I’d welcome your (or Daira-Emma’s) response to these concerns.

1 Like

this ZIP is getting a lot of views on the forum.

i think its the most viewed topic in 2026 and the largest thread since 2025 thread on partnership with proton mail!

not like the views back then, but then theres the price action now seeking “adoption”

1 Like

What I hear you saying is that in this ZIP we have restricted ZCG too much and that our models describing how Zcash needs to understand broad based adoption for becoming a medium of exchange to further secure the network is valuable but should be seen as complementary rather than coupled to the ZCG itself. Is that right?

If so, I can agree with this. I would be happy to propose two ZIPs: one that describes a necessary funding stream specifically for adoption efforts or one that reaffirms the nature of adoption efforts as part of broader development efforts already provided for in an existing funding stream, and one that supplies guidance on grant approval processes specifically for adoption efforts.

If not, what is it you object to exactly? I find the anti-ZCG “compromise” proposal extremely political as well. And what is or is not defined as “political framing” is itself a political debate. At a certain point, being unwilling to listen to a message due to discomfort with any kind of tone is itself just a weapon and these debates have rightfully destroyed a fair amount of belief I had that most people involved are arguing from any sort of good faith, to be honest with you.

2 Likes

@fabacab, I agree that wider adoption helps protect Zcash. My concern is making one definition of adoption a compulsory grant criterion.

Consider three projects. I cite them as examples, not as endorsements or judgements on their merits.

ZecHub receives ZCG funding for education and community work. Its 2026 ZCG grant is USD 433,079.25.

When ZecHub applies for its next grant, would ZCG have to judge not only ZecHub’s own work but also the smaller projects it funds through its DAO against ZAP’s MUST requirement? How much room would remain for experimentation?

Gleyo, which rewards contributors in shielded ZEC, received a USD 4,500 grant from ZecHub DAO, but its separate coinholder retroactive grant application was rejected.

And MeetZec is a new community project providing tools for organising local meetups. Its creator introduced it to seek feedback and contributions, and has not requested funding.

Now, purely hypothetically, suppose MeetZec sought a ZCG grant to improve its guides, translations and meetup directory. (It would more likely approach ZecHub, but bear with me.) Would it satisfy ZAP’s MUST requirement? Its contribution to adoption might be valuable but indirect, and difficult to measure in advance. What evidence would the committee need before it could approve such a grant?

I have also drafted a proposal for a ZecHub Communities sub-DAO, to fund new ambassadors, local meetups and emerging communities through a six-month pilot in 2027.

It would require a USD 57,200 line in ZecHub’s 2027 ZCG grant application, which ZCG would need to approve. Would that satisfy ZAP’s MUST requirement, when much of the value lies in incubating communities before their adoption impact can be measured?

Some grants put ZEC directly into people’s hands. Others build the knowledge, tools and communities that make using it possible. Both can be valuable, but they need different ways of judging success.

Under ZIP 1015, ZCG already has broad discretion to fund work advancing Zcash’s usability, security, privacy and adoption, including community programmes.

And ZIP 1016 says coinholders SHOULD take account of the same factors the ZCG Committee considers in deciding whether to fund a grant.

Look at how coinholders have actually voted. As I examined in The Hand of God, Q3 approved 17 of 37 proposals. Large security and protocol grants passed overwhelmingly. Gleyo and ZecMap were decisively rejected, and Gleyo, which pays people in shielded ZEC, fits ZAP’s definition of adoption better than almost anything.

We cannot tell from those tallies why. But two things follow. Broad rules do not stop funders being selective. And if work that fits ZAP’s definition struggles for funding anywhere, Q3 suggests it is in the coinholder fund, which ZAP does not expressly change.

ZAP renames the ZCG Committee and adds a compulsory adoption test to what it must consider. ZIP 1016 tells coinholders to take account of the factors that committee considers, though it points to ZIP 1015’s original list.

So does your new test carry over to coinholder grants? If so, is it only a factor coinholders SHOULD consider, or a requirement they MUST satisfy?

And if it doesn’t carry over, and the test is needed to protect Zcash against political attacks, why should it bind ZCG but not coinholders?

I’m not arguing for restricting both. I’d prefer to preserve the broad discretion of both.

I welcome your suggestion to split the proposals. Reaffirming funding for broad adoption is one thing. Making a particular definition of adoption a mandatory gateway to funding is quite another.

The revised ZIP already says the ZAP Committee MAY publish non-normative assessment guidance.

So why not leave grant assessment guidance to the committee, where it belongs?

Changes to governance are inherently political. I’m far more sceptical of the other main proposal than of yours. I’ve explained why I think it’s not a good idea.

I agree that what counts as political framing is itself open to debate. Calling something political is not, by itself, an argument against it.

I’m not asking you to soften your tone. There have been ugly accusations made against ZAP that have no place in civilised discourse.

My objection to the revised ZIP isn’t about tone. It sets out a particular theory of political threats, treats broad adoption as a security property (which I agree with), but then uses that reasoning to justify a compulsory grant criterion.

I agree that broad adoption helps protect Zcash. I question whether that particular threat model belongs in a binding governance ZIP.

The issue isn’t whether the argument is political. It’s whether it justifies a binding rule.

What financial system are you referring to? The one that exclusively makes money for investors, or the global economy as a whole?

A viable currency is one that is broadly used, not hoarded and traded in back rooms. The former results in a vibrant economy of scale that makes the currency more stable regarding government meddling and boosts the overall value and longevity of the currency. The latter feels like nothing more than a passing fad of the rich, to be discarded after it has been milked dry.

Let’s say we agree on the need for global acceptance and use. What are some of the most effective ways of getting mass adoption? Clearly hobbyists and enthusiasts have already found it, but they are too small a population to gain enough traction. I think it’s by looking at who the current system is failing first. Second, those who the system is not fulling benefitting, and only then will the more complacent mainstream users notice and start to engage. Who will be the most motivated to take a chance on a new currency? The list you object to is the list of people most likely to see value in Zec and enthusiastically embrace it.

From another post of yours, I understand you are objecting to the retention rate of initial recipients as lifetime users. Rather than rejecting the strategy used by Violet Rollergirl to onboard people, we should remember that this is a giant social experiment, the first of its kind in human history, and that instead of throwing out the whole approach as ‘bad’ without a reasonable alternative for large-scale onboarding, we could be asking questions about how to refine and support continued engagement by those who have been onboarded. It’s about retention. If we look at that problem, suddenly, there is a whole new world of potential projects to be generated off of programming meant to keep people engaged, and incentivize them towards bringing more people to the table. Instead of a broad rejection of a program that is being incredibly successful, we should all look at any weak points that still exist and say, “Yes, Violet’s program, AND…[insert follow-up ideas here]”

4 Likes

So why is not branded as such? Why is there no. “I AFFIRM this is a social experiment with no guaranteed results” on the ZIP?

So, when are you giving away the ZEC and USD you hold? By that logic, holding ZEC is the ultimate crime, as it is not enabling adoption. HODLing? Nope, you must actively pay others for no reason to increase adoption.

Oh wait, the criteria is just “transfer” without KYC. I guess you can just pay your other wallet, that works too.

A late thank you to everyone who made an account here just to tell us how they use Zcash. This wasn’t a friendly thread to walk into, and you did it anyway. I work on node software, and I don’t often get to hear from the people it’s for. It helped.

Earlier I said Zcash is short on people who’ll stand up and say why they need it. You did that here.

Disclaimer: Claude Fable 5.2 was used to re-word and better articulate my view

8 Likes

Thank you for going through the trouble of joining the forums to share your experience.

I think this post is the most clear example of adoption progress I’ve seen.

We now have several different implementations of payment gateways, points-of-sale, payment processors, etc. All in different tech stacks, some custodial, some self-hosted and what not. Yet no increase in vendors.

The reason is because the “I don’t have any place to spend ZEC” problem is not a technical problem, it is a people problem. The kind of work that the @fabacab ZECsy team is doing, engaging one-on-one with people, is exactly what an adoption campaign should look like, and any other adoption campaign should really follow the same blueprint. Funding such efforts should be a focus of the community.

And as it was said elsewhere in this thread, I think it could be a source of very valuable feedback for us developers to build and enhance our apps to support the adoption campaign.

6 Likes

Just as a heads-up, the Zcash Adoption Pool PR has been updated relative to its original version. Here is a rendered version.

4 Likes

Another heads up: the ZAP ZIP has now been merged. Here is the permalink to its merged commit, and here is a rendered display where you can read the merged and current version as of this writing.

2 Likes

You can just read the draft on zips.z.cash: Draft dairaemma-governance-zap: Zcash Adoption Pool (ZAP). (I also linked it in the top post for anyone who doesn’t make it all the way down here.)

3 Likes

Onboarding people to adopt and use Zec in whatever fashion they chose to use I like.

Building Zecboat.com and Zec Non Fungible Thing : Zecboat.com - Zec Non Fungible Thing helps provides encrypted Zec Post Cards to introduce new users to the zcash network and getting Development funding from Zcash Community Grants is challenging even though ZCG has a 100 million USD treasury.

The way I read ZAP an its potential to focus a future ZAP Committee to assist people and development teams and broaden the approval rate for real Zec builders and not just a small group, grows the zcash adoption rate and strengthens the long-term security of the zcash network.

I would hope when ZAP is adopted by the zcash community it would also include a clear path to forming a new legal independent organization to manage its treasury, and invest into people building Zec into the future.

I have supported ZCG and its treasury for years. I believe ZAP is inline and support this zip and will be voting for ZAP as a ZCAP member. I thank the authors for there vision an innovation for broadening access and hard advocacy in this forum and the many discussions required.

Thanks

5 Likes

I think I’m late to the party, but I’m Molly Erikson and I’m also a sex worker writing to say how the onboarding by Violet led me to be a user of Zodl. I went to a workshop she held in the spring and the main reason I did it (aside from her regular promotion of Zodl on our chats and the positive feedback from previous workshop attendees) was I realized paying for ads w my current wallets would put me at risk of being debanked. I wrote about that in a post on bluesky. I have had a number of friends get debanked and it’s one of my worst work fears. The tldr of the post is I’m so relieved and thankful that because of Zodl I’m not worried every month that all the money I’ve ever made will go poof. I don’t know why we (swers) wouldn’t be a use case yall would want- we get debanked. A lot of critical attacks on privacy happen to this population first.

I hadn’t known before the workshop that you could spend the money you received. I was a little spooked because I’d never managed to buy anything w bitcoin, so I’d only ever accepted enough to pay for ads. But when I read Violet’s tutorials it seemed logical and now I am thrilled to accept as much crypto as I can. I hang onto some but I do spend the rest of it: it seems that some of the posters above don’t want that? I’m not sure why, but yes I spend it. I bought advent calendars for my family a few days ago, pretty psyched about that.

The last thing I’ll say is: I’m a fairly vocal proponent of Zodl now. I say the words “crypto but private, like signal” A Lot. I pitch it to clients, I offer to walk them through it, I also pitch it to friends who got off the crypto train when it got weird. I don’t know what most of the acronyms above mean but I do know that electronic, untraceable cash isn’t a hard sell, it’s downloading the app and getting used to the swap and all that. But people understand the general idea and why it’s good. I have a date to walk a friend through it next week, I’ll send them $30 to pay it forward (why $30? Always wondered that). I hope to convert at least one client by New Year’s. I don’t have a pressing reason to do so, I just really like that this money is private and I’m grateful to Violet so I’d like to further the cause.

4 Likes