ZCG gets too much ZEC. Here's our plan to fix that. šŸ›”ļø

Mod Update: This proposal has been withdrawn, see this post:

Hello Zcash Community,

We hear you: ZCG gets more ZEC than it needs. Its 8% of every block now brings in far more than it can spend well.

So here’s what we’d like to do about it: cut our own funding, give back what we don’t need, and put it toward future block rewards instead. ZEC in the NSM is out of circulation, and it’s paid to miners slowly, over decades. ZCG is exploring a proposal to do it, and we wanted to share the idea before we write it up in full. :backhand_index_pointing_down:

  • :scissors: Less. Under current law, ZCG receives about 109,000 ZEC by the 2028 halving. With the taper, it receives about 47,000: less than half.
  • :turtle: Slower. What’s left is spread out to the 2032 halving, shrinking every month.
  • :bank: From the treasury. If the community supports it, ZCG also moves about 36,200 of the ~91,500 ZEC it holds to the NSM: the ZEC it received above the taper schedule. ZCG keeps ~55,200.

In all, about 98,000 ZEC goes from ZCG to future block rewards.


:light_bulb: The Idea : Same 20%, security that doesn’t run out

Every four years, the block reward that pays miners to secure Zcash is cut in half. One day it will be close to nothing, and Zcash will still need to be secure. We think Zcash should start saving for that day now.

Keep the 20% at 20%. Taper the grants. Fill the NSM.

  • :pick: Miners keep their 80%. Nothing changes for them today.
  • :chart_decreasing: Grants taper. ZCG and Coinholder Grants shrink about 3% a month, and end at the 2032 halving.
  • :bank: The NSM fills up. Everything the grants no longer get goes to the NSM (Network Sustainability Mechanism), a reserve that pays future block rewards. From 2032 it gets the full 20%.


:bank: Why Not Send It All to the NSM Now? : The reserve has to last

Other drafts send the Dev Fund to the NSM straight away, but only until the 2028 halving. That fills the reserve fast, then it drains, leaving 20,000–49,000 ZEC by 2040.

The taper fills it more slowly, but keeps going. With ZCG’s donation, it keeps filling the reserve to 2032 and leaves over 200,000 ZEC still in reserve for miners in 2040.


:pick: Better for Miners : When it matters most

The 2028 halving is harder: miners earn about 20% less in 2029 and 2030, and a little less in 2031–32. After that, every halving is softer, and from 2033 miners earn more than current law every year: about 10% more in 2033, 30% more in 2037 and around 50% more in 2041. That’s right when the block reward is smallest and security matters most.


:clipboard: Summary : What changes, and what doesn’t

What changes

  • :scissors: ZCG’s new funding is cut by more than half, and ends at the 2032 halving.
  • :bank: About 98,000 ZEC goes from ZCG to future block rewards, including the treasury donation if the community supports it.
  • :chart_increasing: Over 200,000 ZEC is still in reserve for miners in 2040.
  • :pick: Miners earn less from the 2028 halving to 2032, then more than current law every year from 2033.

What doesn’t change

  • :coin: The 21M cap.
  • :date: The halving schedule.
  • :ice: Issued supply never goes above today’s path. ZEC in the NSM is out of circulation.
  • :puzzle_piece: No new mechanism. It uses ZIP 237’s NSM, which coinholders backed with 96.6% in September.

:soon_arrow: What’s Next

This is a first look, not the final proposal. We’re writing up the full version with all the details: the numbers, the consensus changes and the trade-offs. Then the community decides, through Zcash’s usual governance process.

Until then, tell us what you think :backhand_index_pointing_down:

Should ZCG develop the taper into a full proposal?
  • :fire: Yes, I’m in
  • :thinking: Interested: show me the details
  • :-1: No
0 voters

Thanks,
Zcash Community Grants Committee (ZCG) :shield:

16 Likes

I like this proposal.

2 Likes

Lets loot at a slightly lower rate

It is obvious ZCG/ZCAP has no idea what the issue is. 90%+ of coinholders hate how money is being spent (for instance, at sex conferences with actual sex workers selling themselves while representing Zcash). This bled over into holders realizing ZCG/ZCAP don’t care what coinholders think.

The issue: there can be no taxation without representation. ZCAP is an insular group. You spent 100s of millions in todays dollars on ZSAs which the community voted down by 90% and then kept spending money on it. You elect yourselves to spend money on yourselves with block rewards. It’s a parasitical system and this flaw is deeply immoral when trying to sell Zcash as money.

Maxime has done an outstanding job at documenting how much looting and self serving ZCAP is.

We don’t want you to loot the coffers less, we want to end the block subsidy going to a parasitical group so that Zcash can be sold as fair money.

The original post does nothing to alleviate our concerns - there can be no taxation without representation in a fair money system.

4 Likes

This proposal is infuriating.

Not only does it conveniently extend ZCG’s mandate until 2032, it also does not solve the actual issues at hand.

ZCG allocated a $455K grant to ZSAs using coinholder money, after coinholders voted at 98.6% against ZSAs. This is unacceptable.

Our money is, as we speak, actively being deployed against our own interests. Coinholders are paying for these grants, are paying for the salaries of ZCG committee members, and are the end users. They should be in control.

ā€œIt is hard to imagine a more stupid or more dangerous way of making decisions than by putting those decisions in the hands of people who pay no price for being wrong.ā€ — Thomas Sowell

The reality is that no committee, whether elected by ZCAP or coinholders, can prosper. Committees never work. ZCG is akin to central planning in communist regimes, it cannot work.

The only acceptable solution is to completely abolish ZCG. Let the free market handle it.

7 Likes

Wait!? ZCG can cut it’s own funding?

1 Like

Mind bringing up a proposal that’s NOT either ZSA or ZECsy? ZSAs were a mandate for nearly 4 years, and it was merely being extended. Even then, why only these two?

4 Likes

They can voluntarily decide to hold or redirect it, which is part of why I want them to become a fiat trust instead, governed by a legally binding document.

1 Like

(Image description: Cypherpunk, which Maxime Desalle has a relation to, uses committees extensively, including an Audit Committee, a Nominating Committee, and most ironically, a Corporate Governance Committee)

Why don’t you talk to Tyler at Winklevoss about how you feel about committees?

1 Like

This proposal completely fails to address the concerns of the community:

  • The unaccountability of ZCG and ZCAP when it comes to spending Coinholder inflated funds
  • The dangers of adversaries being able to take over the funds via ZCAP
  • Any justification for what ZCG could use such a still large amount of money for

Completely missed the mark.

5 Likes

But then you can also argue that the sum is only large because of the current ZEC hype cycle. When ZEC was $200 just a couple months back, nobody had any concerns.

But yes, the core issue is accountability, which is only solved by radical restructuring.

i like this idea. still need to think more about it and I would love to see the complete proposal so i can better evaluate it, but this is a good direction that addresses part of the concerns, while keeping the program running. seems like a good middle-ground settlement to stop the ongoing governance wars (which is escalating too quickly in a negative way), but I’m yet to make my mind on that with certainty.

can you please provide the source for this data? where did you take the ā€œ90%+ā€ from?

i’ve started seeing claims like this one with an increased frequency, and this is concerning.

this is concerning because it’s obvious entitlement of other people’s money. very similar to socialist/communist regimes often criticized in the same posts where these claims have landed. for example:

ZCG’s money is nobody’s but ZCG’s money. it’s allocated under a well-documented, governance-approved system, inherent part of zcash’s protocol.

if you don’t like the current state of zcash’s protocol and want to change it: FINE!

i believe we should always keep the culture and ethos of improving ZEC in different ways – governance included.

but as it’s today, this money clearly belongs to ZCG.

it’s ā€œour moneyā€ as much as a miner’s reward is ā€œour moneyā€. it isn’t.

miner’s block rewards belong to the miner who produced the blog, per the protocol.

ZCG’s allocation from the block rewards belong to ZCG, per the protocol, following the same logic.

please, stop calling other people’s money yours. this is the wrong way of campaigning for what you believe is an improvement in zcash governance. it also makes the whole argument look weak, as it seems based in this false premise of entitlement to other people’s money.


EDIT: removed my last question because i found the answer to it later.

4 Likes

But they aren’t. Miners are, and this was decided by consensus in ZIP 1016, and they will be continue to be paid until 2028. Coinholders never raised concerns against it, neither did they raise concerns in this community. All pushback was about ZCG’s structure, not ZIP 1015/1016 itself. All of this pushback is largely corporate, so centered that I can name everyone involved in less than a page.

Unless… the ā€œcoinholdersā€ are actually miners? So your proposal is to redirect money to just… miners?

When Sowell said that, he was referring to the bureaucrats and administrators in the American system, and the full quote ends with

ā€œKnow-it-alls in the school system do not lose one dime or one hour’s sleep if their bright ideas turn out to be all wrong, or even disastrous, for the child.ā€

He was talking about decisions that impact others, but in this case, the money is already earmarked by coinholders for the purpose, so it is not impacting anyone.

Other than miners, that is.

3 Likes

Maxime isn’t getting money from block rewards that makes it much harder for me to onboard bitcoiners. ZCAP/ZCG does.

The committees at Winklevoss capital use their money, not mine. Do you see how this works?

can you please provide the source for this data? where did you take the ā€œ90%+ā€ from

The 98% no funding vote on ZSAs vs ZCAP/ZCG funding them anyways. It is likely higher than 90% (that block rewards with no representation of holders should be funding active sex workers at sex parties) but I was being generous to your side.

1 Like

ā€˜Free market’… I am sure you want it to happen for the sake of the free market, and not for your employers who stand to make what—like tens of millions MORE a year if ZCG goes down

True, which is, again, why I advocate for cessation and restructuring, not dissolution. But even then, a true Bitcoin maximalist would never use a coin, no offense intended, who did a founders reward program at any point. What sort of maximalists are you talking to?

These committees are a legal requirement in a public company.

And I wonder why the US Securities and Exchange Commission would feel fit to, require, in your words, ā€œ[something that] never worksā€. Hmm… a question for the ages…

And if they are so bad, why go public?

Dear Maxim, I wrote about this on Twitter, but I’ll repeat that the question in the Protocol Feature Sentiment Poll for NU7 (the results of which were explicitly described as advisory and non-binding on their own, though I personally consider it the most important voting option) was: ā€œWhat is your general sentiment toward including Zcash Shielded Assets (ZSAs) as a protocol feature?ā€

This was not a vote on whether to halt all work on ZSA. Therefore, ZCG sought available options to preserve the work already done until the community could decide what to do with it next. There were certain loose ends that needed to be tied up; otherwise, we risked losing the value of the work already funded.

4 Likes

This. They are reiterating the same 2,3 grants while ignoring the hundreds of others. Not to mention ZSAs were and still are supported by core protocol developers including those funded by Winklevii.

The same Winklevosses that said, and I quote, ā€œwe must end the USAID of Zcashā€

do you mean the 98% of the 7.25% turnout from all ZEC in circulation?

and that was a well-documented sentiment polling, not a binding decision, especially because of how low the turnout is?

(fwiw, it’s a fairly reasonable turnout against the shielded supply (~24.5%), but i would argue it’s far from being able to represent the sentiment of all zec coinholders with accuracy as something conclusive).

4 Likes