You didn’t see a warning message like this?
what to say to this support agent to understand what is the problem?
send them a link to the transaction on a block explorer.
Your transaction is definitively on the zec network.
I couldn’t say for sure whether or not that is the correct Binance app interface (I dont use Binance). The fact that it didn’t warn you before the tx may indicate that the app is outdated perhaps? Their customer service also sounds kind of strange, not gonna lie. Everything about the tx otherwise looks correct.
“The way you sent funds, does not delivered to Binance” is false. Technically, you cannot block a tx so if they do have custody of that address you sent to, then they absolutely do have it.
1 Like
It should be noted that the money in that address has been swept in a larger tx. The output taddy has extensive history (has spent 265M in zec total)) so it could be Binances main address? I’ll see what I can snoop out. If so, then that may explain the weird customer service conversation, maybe something hadn’t updated the person didn’t know. You should perhaps ask again, citing this new txid.
Adress you sent to, now empty
https://mainnet.zcashexplorer.app/address/t1deKwocmJcumWZnZd849C764QJhgYKLXi6
The sweep tx
https://mainnet.zcashexplorer.app/transactions/1cf49df984020140b1830fe667c7a0a1240eed70f24f74f9a362d26d6af257b9
This is the output addy of that sweep
https://mainnet.zcashexplorer.app/address/t1PKBiv7mtzD9bNafYaqyxaENeiNDbpKxxQ
3 Likes
Hello! Any progress?
1 Like
Shouldn’t Binance be disclosing their ZEC T-addresses in their proofs of reserves?
I don’t see any ZEC addresses in their recent reports. Am I missing something? Disconcerting.
2 Likes
From the few reports I reviewed at the link you posted, it seems they’re only providing proof of reserves for a limited number of coins. I’ll reach out to our contact to check if they publish data for Zcash. Since it’s the weekend, I may not get a response until early next week.
Their website does note that “…the vast majority of Binance’s corporate holdings are stored in wallets that do not form part of the proof-of-reserves calculations.”
2 Likes
ZEC is not part of Binance proofs of reserves (a bit ironic since they use zk snarks for them).
As far as I am aware their hot wallet address is:
https://mainnet.zcashexplorer.app/address/t1PKBiv7mtzD9bNafYaqyxaENeiNDbpKxxQ
I have never been able to locate a Binance ZEC cold wallet, so I assume they don’t have one.
1 Like
Their cold wallet is the largest transparent address on the Zcash 
https://web.archive.org/web/20221113223016/https://www.binance.com/ru/collateral-btokens
Note that this address is constantly communicating with the hot address you specified.
Why they don’t list it as a confirmation is the question. They removed it from the reserve proof program after it crossed the 1.1 million ZEC. I know this because I watch the major Zcash addresses over time. The maximum amount of funds he had was about 2.343 million coins. This was after Zcash was included in the monitoring list.
Including funds at the hot address, Binance had more than 18% of the total coin volume at the moment.
That’s why it was so important to keep Binance as an accessible exchange and create TEX addresses.
10 Likes