Coinholder: Protocol Feature Sentiment Poll

Update for 02-13-26 18:05 UTC

Q1:  ZSA's               election 11    158 ballots
Q2:  NSM                 election 10    112 ballots
Q3:  Burn Fees           election 6     47  ballots
Q4:  Memo Bundles        election 9     55  ballots
Q5:  Explicit Fees       election 5     54  ballots
Q6:  Sprout dep          election 8     58  ballots
Q7:  Tachyon             election 2     181 ballots
Q8:  STARK proof         election 4     44  ballots
Q9:  Dynamic Fees        election 1     90  ballots
Q10: Consensus Accounts  election 7     49  ballots 
Q11: Quantum Recovery    election 3     172  ballots

Keep the votes comin!

:right_arrow: 4 ballots have broken 3 digts!

Current Top 5 (by ballot count)

  • Tachyon
  • Quantum Recovery
  • ZSA’s
  • NSM
  • Dynamic Fees

Current Bottom 5 (by ballot count)

  • STARK proof
  • Burn Fees
  • Consensus Accounts
  • Explicit Fees
  • Memo Bundles

Median (by ballot count)

  • Sprout dep

Avg ballot count

  • ~ 93 ballots

:eyes: :student:

4 Likes

Hey, thanks for doing all the work to enable Zcash voting! Somebody asked me how to vote with their transparent ZEC, so I sent them this link, but they want to know who controls that wallet, and are they going to get their 1 ZEC or 0.1 ZEC back, and also is it 1 ZEC or 0.1 ZEC. Thanks!

I control the wallet since I’m helping organize and administer the poll. The 0.1 ZEC will be sent back after the election ends and the results are published.

1 Like

But add a date to that ballot answer, otherwise it can be re-used in future polls / replay attacked.

4 Likes

Update for 02-15-26 00:00 UTC

Q1:  ZSA's               election 11    183 ballots
Q2:  NSM                 election 10    117 ballots
Q3:  Burn Fees           election 6     54  ballots
Q4:  Memo Bundles        election 9     55  ballots
Q5:  Explicit Fees       election 5     58  ballotsrm 
Q6:  Sprout dep          election 8     59  ballots
Q7:  Tachyon             election 2     186 ballots
Q8:  STARK proof         election 4     49  ballots
Q9:  Dynamic Fees        election 1     95  ballots
Q10: Consensus Accounts  election 7     50  ballots 
Q11: Quantum Recovery    election 3     172  ballots

Keep the votes comin!

:right_arrow: 4 ballots have broken into 3 digts!
:right_arrow: ZSA’s moved back into 2nd place!
:right_arrow: Burn Fees and Explicit Fees move up a slot on the bottom list

Current Top 5 (by ballot count)

  • Tachyon
  • ZSA’s
  • Quantum Recovery
  • NSM
  • Dynamic Fees

Current Bottom 5 (by ballot count)

  • STARK proof
  • Consensus Accounts
  • Burn Fees
  • Memo Bundles
  • Explicit Fees

Median (by ballot count)

  • Sprout dep

Avg ballot count

  • ~ 98 ballots

:eyes: :student:

3 Likes

Wanted to add that latest zallet can be used to verify transparent votes like with zcashd or trezor.

./zallet rpc verifymessage '"t1VydNnkjBzfL1iAMyUbwGKJAF7PgvuCfMY"' '"H3RY+6ZfWUbzaaXxK8I42thf+f3tOrwKP2elphxAxq8tKypwJG4+V7EGR+sTWMZ5MFyvTQW8ZIV0yGU+93JTioA="' '"20251117: 1 Yay; 2 Yay; 3 Yay; 4 Yay; 5 Nay; 6 Nay; 7 Yay; 8 Yay; 9 Nay"' | jq
true
2 Likes

Update for 02-18-26 18:44 UTC

Q1:  ZSA's               election 11    197 ballots
Q2:  NSM                 election 10    124 ballots
Q3:  Burn Fees           election 6     63  ballots
Q4:  Memo Bundles        election 9     60  ballots
Q5:  Explicit Fees       election 5     60  ballots
Q6:  Sprout dep          election 8     67  ballots
Q7:  Tachyon             election 2     198 ballots
Q8:  STARK proof         election 4     53  ballots
Q9:  Dynamic Fees        election 1     102 ballots
Q10: Consensus Accounts  election 7     52  ballots 
Q11: Quantum Recovery    election 3     175  ballots

Keep the votes comin!

:right_arrow: 5 ballots have broken into 3 digts!

Current Top 5 (by ballot count)

  • Tachyon
  • ZSA’s
  • Quantum Recovery
  • NSM
  • Dynamic Fees

Current Bottom 5 (by ballot count)

  • Consensus Accounts
  • STARK proof
  • Memo Bundles
  • Explicit Fees
  • Burn Fees

Median (by ballot count)

  • Sprout dep

Avg ballot count

  • ~ 105 ballots

:eyes: :student:

6 Likes

Crossposting the results of this poll:

2 Likes