Miner Sentiment Poll (Pilot): NU7.1

Alongside the ZCAP poll on NU7.1, which runs until 2:59 UTC on Tuesday, December 1, 2026, we’re piloting an on-chain miner sentiment poll. Miners and mining pools can record their position on the same five questions by signaling in the blocks they mine. Voting opens at block 3,591,200, an estimated 00:00 UTC on Friday, November 20.

Miners secure the network and run the software that network upgrades change. This pilot gives them a transparent, on-chain way to be heard on proposed changes, using the blocks they already produce. Anyone can check the ballots and run the tally themselves.

This is the first time we’re running it, so we want to hear how it goes. If you have comments or suggestions, please reply to this topic.

Voting

Include a ballot in the coinbase of each block you mine between block 3,591,200 and block 3,629,650, inclusive. That’s an estimated November 20 00:00 UTC to December 1 02:59 UTC, so it closes with the ZCAP poll.

Each block counts with the ballot it carries, so you can set your ballot before voting opens and change it at any time. Ballots are public and attributable to the blocks that carry them.

The ballot builder produces a ballot that follows the poll definition. The poll tally summarizes the results.

Links

9 Likes

Thank you for including this, great idea.

A second tally for the pilot, offered as a gift.

The announcement says anyone can check the ballots and run the tally themselves. We took that at its word. We build zpop, a small tool that issues signed receipts for Zcash mining production, and its tooling now reads the coinbase of every block in the voting window, takes the first valid ballot in the script data, and counts it. It is separate code reading the chain on its own, which is what makes it a check rather than a copy.

We will run it across the full window, heights 3,591,200 to 3,629,650, and post the final count in this thread once the window closes on December 1: the split on each of the five questions, the number of ballot-carrying blocks, and the height of every counted block, so anyone can line our count up against the official tally at miner-poll.zfnd.org and find any difference. If the two counts disagree at any point, we will say so here, with the block that differs.

One scope note, stated plainly. Our count covers ballots in coinbase script data, the part any public tally can read. A ballot placed in a shielded coinbase memo is encrypted to the miner’s own address, so no outside count can include it. If pools use that route, those ballots sit outside every public tally, ours included.

1 Like