Hi @daira , your words are always inspiring. Though in this case, the proposal can be twisted, like it’s been already.
The Shielded Adoption pool’s goal, I believe, is to fund initiatives that push adoption for shielded ZEC where it’s needed the most, hence leveraging simple Pareto’s law to actually invest in the 20% giving 80% of the rewards (which in this case is awareness).
Funding direct consumers positions the ZIP as a ‘charity’ program, which I believe was not your intention, because it’s never been in the scope of any Zcash funding initiative (at least that I know of).
Perhaps there are technical solutions that I’m unaware of, but I think a lot of the workflows an unbanked person would need to be convinced about wouldn’t be possible with test transactions. Can they buy a coffee, which I think necessarily involves some conversion to fiat currency?
(I suppose they could buy a coffee from the trainer, who purchased the coffee with grant funds, but that seems like an accounting trick without a difference, and I bet the trainee would be less convinced of the demonstration).
@emersonian has already said it well, but my understanding is that the ZAP ZIP is intended to clarify what was always possible with ZCG because last week there were calls to eliminate or severely curtail the ZCG, in part because some people expressed outrage about the ZECsy team’s work.
As I understand it, if you support things like ZECsy being funded, even though clearly they are not universally praised, then ZAP is asking to affirm that kind of funding mission, with an added requirement that grants argue how they cause true adoption of Zcash.
Showing the steps required to do different things doesn’t require actual funds to be used, it should be illustrative like any other information/education.
Thanks for clarifying your position @povertyhacked. I’d prefer to let individual educators, who know their audiences better than I can, decide the best way to teach/reach their students. I suspect you are right for many audiences and flows, but not all.
Zcash has financial capital. What it’s short on is social and political capital: people who’ll stand up and say why they need it when the pressure’s on. We’ll never be able to buy our way out, but we can build a base. ZCG’s the one approach that we have to do that, and this ZIP points it in that direction.
On private capital filling the gap: if you need a thing built, pay for it. But swap an open grants process for private capital and whoever pays picks what gets built. Everyone else gets a coinholder vote, and what big holders want isn’t the same as what brings in new ones.
The scrutiny’s coming. AI’s got the national security crowd at its back, we don’t. The EU bars exchanges from privacy coins from July 2027, and Zcash is named. The transparent pool will get through that by following the rules. The shielded pool won’t, unless there are people who use it and will say so. That’s what ZAP funds.
People made plans on 1015 two years ago. Cut it short now and the next lot won’t trust a word we say.
Disclaimer: Claude Fable 5.1 was used to reduce my full arguments and for adversarial review of my understanding of the situation.
There’s no neutral. Refusing to fund a group because it’s “political” is a political choice too, and it’s self-defeating. We say Zcash is private money for everyone, on principle. Drop one group because it makes us uncomfortable and it’s not a principle any more. The people we’re trying to onboard will notice, and nobody trusts private money with a comfort list.
Wallets are neutral because everyone can use them. So is money that works for people the banks won’t take. One test for everyone: does this grant get more people holding or using ZEC. A sex worker group that passes gets funded. A church group that fails doesn’t. Same test, both ways.
Disclaimer: Claude Fable 5.1 was used to reduce my full arguments and for adversarial review of my understanding of the situation.
It’s also the efficient choice. The job is turning financial capital into social and political capital, so the test for a grant is how much of that we get per ZEC. Someone the banks already serve can leave as soon as it gets hard. Someone the banks won’t take, or who has paid the price for a lack of privacy, or watched a friend pay it, will fight for a privacy coin, because they know the cost of going without. We want to be the one they fight for. Same ZEC, more devoted people on our side.
The groups that make some of us uncomfortable aren’t a cost of the principle. They’re the best use of ZEC we have.
Disclaimer: Claude Fable 5.1 was used to reduce my full arguments and for adversarial review of my understanding of the situation.
One more thing on private capital: A fund with ten bets is paid on the one that wins.
A coin as likely to die as to double is a fine bet for them, because the portfolio eats the zeros.
Someone who uses ZEC because nothing else works has one bet. They don’t need it to double. They need it to be here next year.
Those are two different coins, and we have to pick. Cutting ZCG for price is the first. Funding an adoption base is the second. Only the second has people who’ll stand up for it. A fund doesn’t testify.
That’s also why going back on 1015 costs more than it seems on the surface.
The people we need are the ones who need us to keep our word. Break it once and they’ll know which coin we picked.
Disclaimer: Claude Fable 5.1 was used to reduce my full arguments and for adversarial review of my understanding of the situation.
Not a mouthpiece for ZF, the views expressed are my own and no one else’s.
ZAP says the ZCG stream “SHALL continue at its existing value and for the duration specified in ZIP 214,” and points it at adoption. The other proposals cut or end it.
My argument isn’t for this ZIP in particular. It’s for any ZIP that spends ZCG’s financial capital on adoption, which is to say on social and political capital. Right now that’s the best use we have for it, and ZAP is the only proposal on the table that does it.
Yes, I used Claude to tighten it, same as you did in #36. The argument’s mine.
Disclaimer: Claude Fable 5.1 was used to reduce my full arguments and for adversarial review of my understanding of the situation.
You didn’t. What you did is called astroturfing, especially when arguments are being forcibly twisted and conmingled, because the “billionaires will control ZCG in favour of VC” was an anti-ZCG argument, which has already been amicably resolved in Future Dev and Legal Defense Fund ZIP by Zooko and Sean Bowe. By painting it as something ZAP is needed to solve is a false dichotomy.
You’re right, I’m sorry about that. I’ve added disclaimers to all of my posts for transparency.
You didn’t. What you did is called astroturfing, especially when arguments are being forcibly twisted and conmingled, because the “billionaires will control ZCG in favour of VC” was an anti-ZCG argument, which has already been amicably resolved in Future Dev and Legal Defense Fund ZIP by Zooko and Sean Bowe.
I don’t believe my arguments qualify as astroturfing as I understand the term, happy to hear out further explanation.
By painting it as something ZAP is needed to solve is a false dichotomy.
I’d be happy to edit the post if you feel that I posed this as a false dichotomy and have any suggestions to help clarify that my issue is regarding credibility, rationality, and risk management.
Note: AI was not used in drafting this post/reply.
People who work for the Zcash Foundation are free to express their own opinions. Not everyone who has a Zcash Foundation title on the forum is representing an official stance of the Foundation.
First, that’s an argument for ZCG, not ZAP. Stop trying to misdirect people.
ZAP is ZCG, pointed at adoption. The big technical work is already funded, and ZCG has more capital than it can spend well there, so each new ZEC into technical grants buys less and less.
Adoption’s barely started, so each new ZEC there buys about what the first one did. Spend where the next ZEC still buys something.
Disclaimer: Claude Fable 5.1 was used to re-word and better articulate my view.
As far as my reading goes, ZAP is a new fund carved from ZCG, which retains the same panelists.
However, I would not like to argue any more. As long as the coinholders affirm this decision this coming vote, it is not taxation without representation, which is my main concern. So if they affirm it, then I have zero objections as its their money.
ZAP is not ZCG pointed at adoption. ZAP is a few politically motivated characters pointed at funding their friends sexual interests. Not a single supporter of ZAP would be okay with funding religious charters, conservative groups, or anything to do with say ICE workers Zcash adoption. They will hide behind oh well ANYONE is free to add a ZIP go ahead go ahead and find supporters of that, but they will vehemently disagree with funding those things even in the face of increasing adoption, and mute all dissidents like they already have in this thread.
I support this ZIP, and I’d back a grant for any of those on the same terms as anyone else: it brings Zcash social and political capital at a good return per ZEC, and it’s legal. That’s not a concession. The authors said as much (#119, #187).
It isn’t a principle if it has exceptions.
The rule treats everyone the same, but the results won’t come out even, because banks don’t turn people away evenly, and the ones they turn away are the ones who keep using ZEC. That’s not a list of causes. It’s a list of who the banks threw out.
Disclaimer: Claude Fable 5.1 was used to re-word and better articulate my view.
Ok I’m impressed that you think this way with no exception, Daira immediately found a gotcha which you can see in post #187 by saying oh those things are discriminating. I will continue to find it extremely hard to believe that the writers involved in the ZIP will ever allow zcash funds to be used on what they undoubtedly feel is fascist/racist/bigot even though its just a matter of opinion, but you are perfectly unbiased.
It sounds like you basically stand for spending the full ZCG treasury on literally anything that reaches consensus. We disagree on that and I prefer the sbowe+zooko zip but it’s great that we both shared our differing opinions here and participated in governance.
Not quite. I’d rather treat the treasury like an endowment than spend it down. Where I probably differ is that I think low social and political capital is a big risk to Zcash, so I’d spend the stream fairly quickly in the short term to fix that.
And credibility. People made plans around 1015. Cut it short now, on the people who’ve backed us hardest, and everyone learns what our word is worth. That costs more than the ZEC.
Agreed on the rest, glad we both got our views down.
Disclaimer: Claude Fable 5.1 was used to re-word and better articulate my view.