I think that this point is not getting enough attention in the discussion of this ZIP.
This is the piece that makes me strongly support the ZIP, because this should be an additional requirement for ALL grant recipients. If you’re going to take a grant from the ZAP, you need to be able to explain not just what your spiffy tech is going to be, but exactly the mechanism by which it promotes adoption. I think that if we look at some past grants through this lens, we could have avoided awarding some that provided essentially no benefit for the ecosystem.
“Raising awareness” is never enough. Increasing adoption is about identifying specific mechanisms by which grants promote ongoing use in a particular market.
Yes they are. The ZIP means what it says — it’s not a “gotcha” that the categories don’t only include the left, it’s the intent.
However, both of these examples are still excluded, correctly, without the ZIP needing to do so explicitly. The ZCG grant process requires, and has always required, that grant applicants follow the Code of Conduct for this forum, which among other things insists on "respectful interaction, free of harassment or discrimination, regardless of: [list of items that includes “Race or ethnicity”]. White nationalists would be excluded on this basis. Foreign Terrorist Organizations are excluded on legal grounds, consistent with ZIP 1015. That’s just the status quo, not a new thing being proposed.
This is simply incorrect. There is no role for coin-weighted polling whatsoever in any published Zcash protocol governance process. The only current ZIP that defines a role for coin-weighted polling is ZIP 1016, and only for the Community and Coinholder Fund. Specifically:
Non-requirements
Any changes to the ZCG or its governance, such as its expansion to include more members, may be desired but are specifically outside this proposal’s scope.
Any changes to Zcash protocol governance, specifically what changes are made to consensus node software, are outside this proposal’s scope.
That’s why I objected vociferously, and still object, to the NU7 coinholder sentiment poll having been treated as an effective veto on ZSAs.
As I’ve said many times, if the proponents of coin-weighted polling want a role for it in protocol governance, they should write a ZIP saying so, and then the community can debate that ZIP and come to some compromise by social consensus. Unless and until that happens, it has no formal role.
But how do you KNOW they violate the code of conduct? Not like they are being the KKK on this forum. They will just do so offline, using the funds! The ZCG’s existing mandate does NOT require KYC for grants below $50,000, and in the “status quo” they are paid via shielded funds without ANY verification.
The existing grants process is insulated because the law defines a technological grant (where you expect a deliverable in exchange for the grant) and an as-is grant (where you just pay people out because of themselves) very differently. Even then, ZCG is forbidden from paying Iranians, the law just gives them a free pass because they do not know and did not bother to check as it was irrelevant to the receiver (which was “the creator of the deliverable”, not “X person”)
But in this case, the deliverable (“adoption”) is directly linked to the person, and thus ZCG can no longer claim they are not aware. They are no longer paying to “creator of the deliverable”, they are paying the person themselves.
Are we requiring KYC for all grants regardless of amount, like I suggested previously then? A central database? If not, then how can any exchange regulatorily justify listing Zcash when they might be in violation of AML laws globally? Zcash will become a PARIAH.
It takes ONE SINGLE CASE leaking to CoinDesk or the Block, or worse, the NYT that “Republican-backed Zcash funds the IRGC via goodwill programs without any checks; IRGC uses the money to hijack ships and kill US personnel”, Zcash is DEAD.
It gets better, actually. The reason Tornado Cash didn’t kill Ethereum was because the block validators didn’t earn money from it: US and Allied validators simply dropped its transactions from their mining pool, meaning they were no longer profiting from it, and non-US validators would process it. Since the US validators were earning nothing from it, they weren’t in violation of sanctions. But in this case, ZCG’s “tax” is taken from EVERY miner, meaning if you knowingly keep mining Zcash, you are in violation of US sanctions law. Every single US miner, from Cypherpunk (20-25% of hashpower), to Fortitude (20-25% of hashpower) to half of ViaBTC (40-50% of hashpower) would leave the network at lightning speed.
But nobody is saying it was illegitimate. Everyone’s point is that the coinholders clearly didn’t want it, so the coinholders wishes were not respected, so the appeal is to OTHER coinholders to vote against keeping ZCG. Nobody is accusing ZCG of anything, they are just pointing out facts for other coinholders to consider when making a decision, which is their right to do.
Exactly. Zcash already has incredibly widespread “awareness” but it’s rate of adoption is abysmal.
Moreover, “awareness” is not necessarily good. Almost everyone I know HATES Zcashers because you are all just bullshit scammers or evil crypto bros to basically everyone I regularly speak to on a daily basis.
And the behavior by some of you on this forum proves them right.
So they are very aware of this project but if it were not for me they would have never adopted this project as a tool for their own daily financial life.
ZECsy has a clear, well-defined strategy and a perfect product market fit because both sellers and buyers in our use case want what shielded Zcash offers.
I am attending the Cypherpunk Congress in Mumbai now and I had an interesting conversation in which I was able to assist a business man struggling to match music makers (artists) with customers (music lovers) and the solution I proposed that he got SO excited about was a Zcash adoption program. We discussed it further and I encouraged him to apply for a grant from ZCG. I intend to help him apply because I think I can refine his thinking about how to keep ZEC as ZEC within the ecosystem for both the musicians and the fans.
Anyways, the point is that this grant should stand on the merit of how well its adoption story is told and actually plays out. I don’t think the use case for his music service is controversial and I don’t think his adoption story is as compelling as ZECsy’s, but the point is the adoption metric is the only consideration an adoption program such as ZAP should care about.
The fact that opponents of this ZIP are losing their minds over the specific examples was intended to show how two-faced those opponents really are.
The community should expect an updated ZIP in short order. @daira and I are working hard to integrate the little bit of useful feedback from @tiagodetox and other people who have engaged in good faith instead of blatantly vapid morality. We look forward to continuing this iterative process to improve the adoption of Zcash for everyone.
It shouldn’t need to be said but thank you for an honest (and constructive) question instead of what people in this discussion are otherwise doing (just attacking each other).
No, I don’t agree with that. The framing that giving people ZEC for their own personal use would be informative/educational/marketing is a product of choosing something you want to do and then trying to make it permissible and warping the meaning of those words - it’s fallacious. The proper way to consider it, as a matter of interpretation, would be to consider what is informative/educational/marketing and then do that. Paying a group of people ZEC to go out and educate ‘x’ group would be permissible, but not just giving funds to ‘x’ to use of their own accord. That likely isn’t direct enough for some but that’s a personal issue and is the proper way of doing something both in terms of the wording of that ZIP and the idea that SoV taxed funds should be neutral (outside of promoting itself maybe).
All of the categories of people mentioned, regardless of people’s views, need (or at least could benefit from) Zcash but the proper way to allocate the tax in this regard is empowering people to choose to buy Zcash and/or use it. It can be direct as funds being used to help people purchase Zcash themselves or helping them shield it etc. handing Zcash for people to use, however, is trying to achieve equal outcomes based on assumption of that those not in those categories’ outcome is.
This request, as framed, is trying to good stuff and anyone arguing otherwise is a fool. Trying to do something good doesn’t make it right though. The issue more so is the directness of the steps wanting to be taken. If community programs to help people purchase and thereafter use Zcash themselves isn’t direct enough, individuals can elect to use their own funds to buy Zcash for whoever they wish (as is their right).
With all due respect with the amount of hacks we are seeing today, it seems far easier for terrorists to get money by hacking than by applying to a grant, WORKING and getting the milestone for then perpetrate a terrorist attack. You scenario is really farfetched and if it were to happen, it could actually happen with retroactive grants as well.
Edit
Furthermore: terrorist attacks deliverately plan indentity and attribution messages on the evidence they leave behind for authorities to “find”. Like passports that are found in an arsoning attack that didn’t get burnt. If the objective of a Zcash adversary was to link Zcash to a criminal organization, they can easily fabricate that by commiting crime and leaving a “smoking gun” that points to Zcash. I repeat, there is nothing, no KYC, no mechanism at all that can avoid this supposed attack vector if it were to exist.
… Not terrorist attacks, I mean terror funding in general. Sanctions law does NOT require a terrorist to say “Zcash funded me”, merely providing any “material benefit” to a FTO in most jurisdiction qualifies as a sanctions violation on its own. That’s why an independent report is explosive. Just take the US v. SPLC case. SPLC was funding KKK for a good cause allegedly, for spying. But because funds were moved, they were funding something illegal, which is… prohibited.
Except ZAP does not require work, ZCG does. In ZCG’s scenario, it is INDEED far-fetched. Not in this ZIP.
How? Retroactive grants require work to be performed.
The entire issue is that ZAP does not require you to do work, it is a reactive funding program reacting to perceived need without KYC, while ZCG is proactive funding after appropriate vetting.
This isn’t unbacked. EU charity law requires disclosing, vetting and recording the “class of beneficiaries” of any charity being provided, under 5th AMLD, as a general class that will be catered to. If an individual recipient is named for a purpose that does NOT benefit a “class”, then UBO requires vetting that named recipient. Since this ZAP does not donate “in cause” (which could be justifiable), rather, proposes granting charity to named recipients…
I might have time for a longer reply later, but first, thanks for your reply.
Second, I’m still not sure we are communicating. I’m not asking about “give money to x group” as a fundable grant, I’m asking about "give money to a team who will train and educate x group, and in the process give trainees a small amount of ZEC so they can see how it really might work in their lives, but the vast majority of grant funds goes to the trainers, materials, travel, etc… " Maybe you object to that too, but based on what you’ve written, I’m unsure.
@divijpandya@paulbrigner I would ideally like for you, as acclaimed lawyers, to weigh in on the impact of Holder v. Humanitarian Law Project on this proposal. As I am aware, the court ruled that even for a humanitarian cause, if the money were to be transmitted to an FTO, it is still illegal.
Statements by the Ndrangheta recorded on tapes (Camorra and Rome’s “Mafia Capitale” syndicate tapes) show that organised crime and FTOs regularly exploit charities and EU welfare via “sockpuppeting” via migrants, and this behaviour is still prohibited as they are classed as FTOs or OCSs, even though the money (or a portion of it) is going towards someone who needs it.
If this ZAP were to provide ZEC anonymously as a “charity” to people in need, and an organised crime syndicate (OCS) or a FTO were to “farm” it, what will the legal fallout be, compared to Tornado Cash, especially since US validators didn’t profit from Tornado Cash at large, but US Zcash miners will here?
I believe the ZCG funds projects like these already provided they have verifiable metrics, and thus why is a new ZAP needed for it? Evidence: the ZECsy project itself, funded by ZCG.
I wouldn’t support any amount being given to directly distributed to trainees. I think all of the other costs are important and would be worthwhile- if the idea is to showcase the value Zcash could/would have to their life, part of the costs allocated to that session could include an amount for the trainees to use in rest transactions. Those funds should remain owned by the grant recipient and/or the fund. The trainees would, however, be able to see first hand the value of Zcash. This way, I believe the objectives of both the ZIP and this request would be achieved whilst retaining the ZEC for further/future use.
I’ll start by saying I haven’t read through the ~200 comments in the thread (trying to work through that today), and I need to take a closer look at the ZAP.
Am I a lawyer? Yes. Acclaimed? Far from it! Can’t dispense anything that could be construed as legal advice, especially over the internet.
How likely are we to see bad actors apply for funding? Note that anything over a certain amount does require KYC per the grant application rules. If someone receives funding and then misuses it for criminal activity, I’m not sure what liability looks like for ZCG in that case, but this underscores why it’s important for us to establish a legal defense fund (LDF). Idk if ZCG would be the one sued since, as I understand it, FPF is the one that transmits the funds. Either way, we don’t want anyone getting sued, so everything should be done carefully against sensible criteria for grants–in this case, I think it’s more about the process being defensible in case something like this ever happens.
To clearly affirm that these funds should be used for Zcash adoption as intended, and not suddenly stolen and sent to miners/NSM.
ZCG provides an invaluable governance balance to coinholder directed funding.
Rather than ordering ZCG to throw its money away - something that no governance process ever defined as even being possible - the Zcash Adoption Pool ZIP affirms that this money should be used responsibly over time as originally intended, and further emphasizes that educating at-risk people on how to use Zcash spreads its circulation.
I believe that ZCG/ZAP should re-organize to scale, not retreat - defining a ten year treasury plan, and having a larger team to iterate on governance and determine how and when to best deploy this capital.
Many critics here clearly did not read the ZIP and instead skimmed to the Examples section, without even reading its preface that each proposal would require a vote, just like today.
This is the community’s money that billionaires are trying to reallocate, by voting with their money. Don’t forget that NSM money will end up in the hands of miners, and the world’s largest Zcash miner started all of this drama, suggesting that money be taken from the community and given to their mining profits.
Indeed. If the ZAP is put to a coinholder vote, and gets a direct coinholder mandate, it is much better than the ZCG’s funding being surreptitiously redirected without consent, which looks MUCH better.