I want to be clear about my objection. I am not against helping people, and I am not against adoption. My problem is what the ZAP requirement actually measures.
The ZIP says grants must show that funds will be “further disbursed” to increase the number of individuals who hold or transact ZEC. That is a proxy, and it is an easy proxy to game. If 50,000 people receive ZEC in transparent addresses and just hold them, the score goes up. The network does not gain anything. No new shielded activity, no tested code paths, no stronger protocol. We would have paid for a number on a dashboard.
My second problem is the list of examples. It mixes two very different things in one list:
Privacy projects and contributors in need of legal defence. This is infrastructure. If a core developer ends up in prison for the software they wrote, Zcash itself suffers. The Tornado Cash case is exactly what could happen to one of our own developers. Funding this protects the protocol.
Refugees, trans people needing hormones, homeless people, abortion funds. These are real human needs, and many of these people genuinely benefit from private money. But funding them does not advance Zcash. They would use any private payment tool. The causal link to the protocol is weak.
Putting these in the same list makes disagreement look like cruelty. If you question the second group, you appear to be against privacy, or against vulnerable people. But these are two separate questions:
Should we protect the people who build and maintain this technology? Yes.
Should community funds, taken from coinholders, pay for social causes that are unrelated to the technical health of the network? No.
And here is the part that shows the metric is broken. If I support detransitioning clinics or pro-life movements, which local laws make hard to fund, I could write a grant that scores perfectly under this ZIP. More holders, more transactions, zero infrastructure, zero shielded usage. A committee that approves one side of that list has no neutral reason to refuse the other side. Then the committee becomes an editor of political content, using other people’s coins. That is not neutrality, and it is not what ZIP 1015 was for.
So I would support this ZIP if it changed two things:
Replace “number of individuals holding ZEC” with something tied to actual shielded use: monthly active shielded transactions, or shielded UTXO movement coming from funded on-ramps. Harder to fake, and aligned with what keeps Zcash alive.
Add an explicit exclusion: advocacy campaigns, identity politics, and direct transfers of value to protected categories are not eligible. Fund what makes it possible or easier to use ZEC shielded (wallets, tooling, audits, legal defence of developers, measurable onboarding). Do not fund causes that would exist with or without Zcash.
That line is neutral on politics. Detransitioning clinics and abortion funds end up on the same side: both excluded, because neither builds capacity to use the protocol. I think this is close to the original intent of ZIP 1015, which speaks of development “or other work” for the public good of the Zcash ecosystem. The public good of the ecosystem, not the general social good at large.
I would reject this proposal. Any such grant design is flawed in my opinion and political (albeit well intentioned). I do not believe grants should be given for progressive ideologies or conservative ideologies.
The Zcash dev tax is to support development and developers. Picking a group of people to benefit from that tax based on one group of people’s alignment is misguided, however well intentioned. “Zcash is for everyone” is important but that does not mean it’s handed to people (for whatever reason) out of funds from the dev tax. Zcash being for everyone simply means anyone can acquire it. If someone can’t acquire it, someone can give it to them from their own personal holdings/purchases (for whatever reason).
Even if the tax shouldn’t be thought of as a dev tax, the point remains: a store of value should not prioritise any person or group of persons- it is meant to be neutral. Don’t make the mistakes that the Ethereum Foundation did.
Equality, not equity as a mechanism of reform. The desired result has to be equal opportunity, not equal outcome. The grant request would be on the wrong side of these last two sentences.
All of the above said, if the grant request scope is changed so that funds are used to educate people - which one could reasonably argue is needed more for the categories of people sought to be advocated for in this grant request - on Zcash (empowering them to make informed decision(s) about using Zcash (or not)), I would vote in support in a heartbeat.
I’m in opposition of this proposal. This type of thinking can quickly devolve into the justification of funding all unbanked use cases, regardless of political or religious affiliation, and can become very dangerous. Do we want Zcash funding anti hate groups while simultaneously funding pro hate groups and international terrorism?
Like so many other community members have stated already, let’s focus on improving security and scalability of the network. By doing so, price will follow and price is the greatest marketing tool a token can ask for.
I wholeheartedly disagree with this statement. It is precisely the use of money for social causes that is the measure of the health of this network.
If Zcash cannot or is not used for purposes that fiat money is unavailable for or censored by, then Zcash is not “unstoppable private money.”
For the record, I also teach Monero but I prefer Zcash because the community argument has historically been stronger. The discussion on this ZIP may prove that this is no longer true.
The instant a better alternative to Zcash exists, I will instantly abandoned this project and this community in favor of the better option by the above metric. And I will do so loudly because that is how I protect myself, my community, and the very concept of unstoppable private money in the first place.
Zcash is not unstoppable private money. It is merely stoppable private money, which all coinholders agree it is by your definition.
If the teaching involves the community donating funds, then I am afraid it is indeed no longer true. Monero probably does offer free Monero to teach people about Monero, try there?
You should, actually. There are much better alternatives to Zcash out there that are actually unstoppable private money by your definition. Zcash, on the other hand, which prefers taxation with representation, is stoppable.
In fact, you should also do so vocally, and when you do it, please explicitly announce that you are doing it specifically because ZAP is getting pushback. PLEASE mention ZAP if you happen to tweet on Twitter or go to Coindesk.
your argument, and some of the arguments made in the zip both argue for maximizing moral responsibility, not value creation.
financial responsibility, in a free market, necessarily maximizes value creation, whereas moral responsibility maximizes good conscience but not value creation. most of the zip’s proposals clearly tend toward moral responsibility while neglecting financial responsibility.
don’t get me wrong, you can be both financially and morally responsible: you can produce value (and revenue, which means capturing some of that created value) for people whose property rights are being actively violated by the State, for example prostitutes and trans people.
if you just maximize moral responsibility with near zero regard for financial responsibility you are just going to waste funds without creating much value.
That is exactly what funding education and disbursement programs is doing according to the original ZIP. Your presumption that the funds should only be used for (technical) development is all of narrow minded, immoral, and a misreading of the fund as it was created. Our proposal here makes ZERO changes to that.
Since we are forgetting this, observe:
As specified in ZIP 1015:
The stream allocated to Zcash Community Grants (ZCG) is intended to fund
independent teams entering the Zcash ecosystem, to perform major ongoing
development (or other work) for the public good of the Zcash ecosystem, to the
extent that such teams are available and effective. The ZCG Committee is given
the discretion to allocate funds not only to major grants, but also to a
diverse range of projects that advance the usability, security, privacy, and
adoption of Zcash, including community programs, dedicated resources, and other
projects of varying sizes.
There is no shortage of projects that fulfil these criteria and that are in
desperate need of funding.
Wow. You’ll suffer exactly one project aimed at expanding adoption to groups outside conservatives’ (and some liberals’) comfort zone to exist. For fear of upsetting specific billionaires and losing the rest of ZCG funding. (Literally, we’ve discussed this privately. I wouldn’t normally reveal anything from private conversations but I think it’s significant and publically relevant that that’s the whole reason you expressed in that conversation.)
Your “unstoppable private money” argument conflates two distinct concepts:
Protocol-Level Censorship Resistance: Zcash transactions cannot be blocked by third parties.
Governance-Level Grant Allocation: The ZAP committee decides which projects receive funding.
These are not the same thing. The fact that a grant committee declines a social cause has nothing to do with whether Zcash is “stoppable.” If we accept this logic, every VC fund, government, or grant committee that rejects a proposal is “censoring” it.
This is a conclusion reached via redefinition. “Unstoppable” in crypto means no third party can block your transactions. It does not mean “the governance fund must finance whatever a given group wants.”
Finally, leaving the project is a personal choice, not an argument.
The real question: Why should the Zcash Community Grants fund, explicitly created for technical development and ecosystem public goods, be redirected into political advocacy for a subset of the community?
This is the most comprehensive touch-grass/reality-check paragraph I have ever read in this forum.
I asked gemini who many car drivers there are in the world and it said they were around 2 billion. then I asked it how big the car enthusiast industry was and it said around 200 and 600 millions. Then I asked what about mechanics and it said 7 million.
The numbers are not important but the proportions. Even for something as common and popular as cars, most of the people don’t care about how the car they drive works. They want the car to take them to their destination.
Then I asked “how much money did the car industry invest so that using a car is as well known as it is?”
The automotive industry has spent trillions of dollars over the last century to institutionalize car ownership and normalize driving as a fundamental part of daily life. Today, global automotive advertising and marketing alone costs $41.59 billion annually
Interesting!
So I asked Gemini “how were the initial campaigns when the consumer automotive industry was being born?”
When the consumer automotive industry was born in the early 20th century, cars were far from a necessity—they were loud, dangerous, expensive toys for the wealthy. To turn the automobile into a mainstream commodity, early advertising campaigns had to completely reshape how people thought about status, geography, and public safety.
Holy moly! So it appears that people HATED cars to begin with? Isn’t that similar to what @your.angel.avery just said?
Maximizing moral responsibility is valuable. It directly contributes to the health of Zcash and is also a direct contributing factor to the speedy adoption of Zcash, as people like doingmybest has explained above.
Maximizing the moral responsibility of this specific ecosystem is not just critical for the adoption of this technology but it is in a very special way central to the value proposition of this project in the first place.
You cannot separate the moral responsibility of the Zcash stewards from the value created by the network. Believing that this is possible misunderstands what money is.
I am difficult. I am famously difficult on matters of ethics, in fact. Hi, my name is Violet. And you are just beginning to see how much I care.
But “do what I want or I leave” is the market working exactly as you say it should. Selling coins is leaving. Everyone can do this if they want. If you check Twitter you will see influential users who hate trans people and hate sex workers threatening to sell their bags over this ZIP. This is success as far as I am concerned.
If you believe as I do that Zcash is for everyone and that ZIP 1015 should be used exactly as described in that ZIP to increase the adoption of Zcash among people who currently do not have it and that this will be good for them, good for us, good for the network, and good for humanity, then you should buy Zcash and use it.
If you believe, as they do, that Zcash is turning woke and wokeness is bad and that you should not participate in an economy that keeps sex workers and trans people housed, that offers circumventions for financial censorship for debanked people, and that its governing bodies should abandon the people who need censorship resistant money or that you simply feel so morally blighted by association with such people, then you should sell your coins.
That is the market deciding. I welcome it.
Why is my behavior here under such scrutiny as an “ultimatum” and theirs not?
I didn’t mean it that way it just seemed since fabacab replied like my post was directly aimed there I figured you may have announced you switched to that acct somewhere in the thread and I missed it for some reason. I understand thats a jump but it was late and my post was literally aimed at you and fabacab’s reply was like you cant tell me I do so and so and thus my brain jumped there. No harm intended!
And then your edited post, yes, THAT second post of mine was aimed at fabacab, only my first post was aimed at you. So I did not misquote you, I was replying but I am guessing you got it since you deleted the post.
Even coinholder-person polling is a subpar representation. Also discussed before. Be on the lookout also for a video interview between myself and @daira recorded during Zcon7 this past week shortly to be released by @ryan.taylor and the ZK AV Club about this very issue.
The fallacy that today’s polling methods represent the tens of thousands of Zcash users out there is a big problem. And none of these methods can represent the billions of potential users, who we must also consider as stakeholders of our actions if we are truly trying to change the monetary system such that they can participate in it.
Failure to even consider the impact on people who cannot vote is violent monetary colonialism, and wrong. Voting should never be binding on decision. It is one useful information-gathering signal that must be weighed against many other inputs, collected differently.
Perfection is not the goal, nor my expectation. But you are proposing a change in the governance process when you say “just let coinholders vote with their money.” Coindholder-amount voting is not the established process as written and would not be a legitimate way to change the process. I am merely holding you all to your own written standards.
It is absolutely disgusting that it is left to me and @daira to remind you all of this. The two trans people who have received the most vile hatred and the least support from the most influential and powerful members of this community. Do better. All of you.
Wait I’m proposing a change? How is it not currently discussion + dev suggestions + coinholder? That’s how we did NSM 7 voting. I’m fine with continuing whatever process we used there. I thought that was a great example of how everyone came together and figured out what was important re tachyon and block times and ZSA’s and whatever else.
I actually thought you were advocating for a change in the existing methods based on what you were saying. I was not trying to change the status quo! The existing method is fine.
Any chances on toning down the oh this is disgusting oh this is the hatred this is the violent colonialism stuff? Respectfully. I do not care about fixing all your problems in the world with zcash I just want to be able to multisig and spend it everywhere and have it be really fast. Its money. I understand the trans stuff is a very personal issue for you but consider other perspectives as well, not everyone cares about it but since we ALL care about the money and performance part lets focus on that common ground in the official channels. Thats a great way to put it, lets focus on the common threads