Then re-read the ZIP we proposed, omg. Actually read it.
A change to the status quo is what the “compromise” reached through manufactured emergency consent does. This ZIP retains the status quo and changes nothing.
All it does is point out what the earlier ZIP says. That you are all freaking out about it lays bare the fact that you did not actually implement the earlier ZIP.
And now that I am holding the community’s feet to the fire about what implementing it actually means, so many of you are suddenly clutching your pearls and wringing your hands about the fact someone might make you actually follow through.
I will tone this down when you tone up the pushback to this form of speech against me and my community.
Until then, no. That is the social contract.
It is not acceptable or reasonable to expect me to be civil in the face of incivility. If you do not denounce hatred against me and mine in the strongest possible terms then I feel no obligation to hold my tongue about you. Show me where you do this in order to gain my respect for doing this.
Telling me that “not everyone cares about trans stuff” while saying nothing to the people lobbing cruel and vicious attacks at a trans member of your own community is not a way to win a trans person’s respect, fucking obviously?
Lack of pushback against transphobia from Zcashers slows adoption of Zcash. Help me speed it up by pushing back against that. Consider it a cultural security issue if you must conceptualize things in inhumane ways. But do it.
This is the same exact dynamic as @your.angel.avery and @doingmybest pointed out above. Zcash is losing users by not engaging on the cultural issues those users care about simply because some hypothetical other users don’t. And this self-defeating political “neutrality” is making my job of onboarding those users harder, too.
I read it, it’s just tricky, since the core issue I and many others have brought up with ZCG is that they have all this money and can unanimously choose to use it on stuff people don’t want (such as: avax bridge, ZSA) and this proposal is like oh but lets continue exactly as things are. It’s kind of like this is trying to do the one thing we’re trying to protect against where a few elected people can self deal into their own interests instead of have a vote and more reasonable process like NU sentiment polls.
“If you do not denounce hatred against me and mine in the strongest possible terms then I feel no obligation to hold my tongue about you”
Sure thats fair, you can talk to me however you want. It was a request but so is yours and thats reasonable. I don’t care about transexual problems and wish we would focus on zcash performance, upgrades, etc, but of course when something is a core part of your identity you are free to make every possible thing about the issue that most concerns you. I don’t care about onboarding porn stars when there is no working multi sig solution yet. I don’t care about housing people I think there’s enough welfare in america already. I just want the best money possible created and then people will use it.
It is what it is. Good luck in your zec takeover to advance your agenda. We’ll see who wins!
I wrote a ZIP with @daira and @emersonian that holds y’all to account for what you actually wrote earlier in ZIP 1015.
Now you are afraid that funds will be used to onboard users you don’t care about. But I do. So the question becomes, who matters more? You and your use case or me and mine? Or do we matter equally and have equal access to the network and its benefits?
Zcash is either for everyone, or it is for financial “privacy” but only as long as you approve of my spending. It cannot be both.
I am explicitly forcing a cultural and ethical crossroads from everyone in the Zcash community so that we can address this existential question about the network and its social layer.
So are you a 1 or a 0? This makes clear what the choice is.
I am not interested in “taking over” Zcash. But other factions clearly are; the VC-backed power and money grab that spurred this debate is in fact a shift in power and a hostile takeover.
I am interested in stress testing it so that it becomes more secure and so that I can be assured that it remains unstoppable private money as useful to those I disagree with and don’t like as it is useful to me.
Part of that is a technical implementation. But part of that is governance. Technology can change when governance does.
I am not above pentesting Zcash culture, community, or governance to determine the reality of a situation with the currency, network, or contributors.
No I don’t think you really made some grand incredible gesture like you think, out of 150 posts I counted roughly 6 for and 13 against and some neutral from about 27 unique accounts, 19 of which had clear positions. Landslide no victory for you. There is , fundamentally, no scenario where any type of vote or poll is going to favor spending ZCG funds on ‘housing trans’ instead of improving the technology. We both know this, which is why this type of show of power thread where the funds just effectively have to be held hostage and shibboleths like “we should represent billions of people that we cant poll” are out and about.
The ZCG treasury is highly unlikely to be pillaged by you to advance trans agendas, you will move on to some other coin maybe eth or avax and try the same thing there, and hey maybe it will work. But Zcash will be unstoppable private money regardless. ZCG money should be spent on technology not social justice.
If this zip wins over the others, then cool. We’ll see if that happens.
This may shock you but sex workers are normal people who use fiat & ZEC for normal expenses like food, shelter & all kinds of life necessities that are not your business to police or monitor.
Zcash is for Everyone. Even people you are prejudiced against. But your prejudice is far to late to gatekeep ZEC from sex workers. We’ve been here for years holding, trading, supporting, arguing, voting, building & promoting adoption. You didn’t even know until you got mad about a grant. That’s the power of permissionless privacy
ZAP is a wonderful idea & is clearly necessary if we are to be serious about true inclusiveness for Everyone
This may shock you but they are normal people who use fiat & ZEC for normal expenses like food, shelter & all kinds of life necessities that are not your business to police or monitor.
Zcash is for Everyone. Even people you are prejudiced against. But your prejudice is far to late to gatekeep ZEC from the above people. We’ve been here for years holding, trading, supporting, arguing, voting, building & promoting adoption. You didn’t even know until you got mad about a grant. That’s the power of permissionless privacy
ZAP is a wonderful idea & is clearly necessary if we are to be serious about true inclusiveness for Everyone, especially them, isn’t it?
Further, white nationalists and FTOs are ironically fully covered under “debanked individuals”
The FBI regularly seizes bank accounts associated with the KKK
Of course, we should stop it! We should vet the grantees first! That means we need to collect exact data of the grantee to do a background check… to dispense a private currency.
Now this I call an amicable and rational argument, which is more than I can say for others. I respect you for saying that, and I fully agree: if this is properly put to a coinholder vote, then I will fully accept the results as legal.
If not, then it’s taxation without representation.
“yes, we should dump all of the existing fund into eliminating [insert group] ‘injustice’.”
this is the same argument as “[insert billionaire] should donate 50% of his wealth to feeding the starving african children for a year”
this benefits zec in no way. maybe it lifts the “value” of zec in the minds of sex workers. it will not do this in the broad leftist sphere since they already hate crypto, owing to it’s right-wing association.
this is a black hole for resources and the return on investment is most likely tiny.
what could work, is good old capitalism, where you provide some form of value for these [insert group] and they pay you, both benefit. Problem solved! without using miner funds for charity.
This comment seems to be veering off into political issues that are off topic.
However, to address if it benefits ZEC, yes it does. You want a billion users? This is how you get a billion users. Marketing & education for demographics with perfect PMF. The return on investment is broad adoption. That is literally good old capitalism.