Highlander proposals?

[mistfpga]

Hi,

I am a little confused as to how this works. Is a proposal meant to be all encompassing trying to cover everything in one go, or can/should we have a multitude of proposals that can work together and pick and chose from each parts.

For example I really don’t get governance. I get decision making, etc. but I don’t understand the implications of different types (as been made painfully obvious on these forums) so with my proposals I would like to simplify them as much as possible and remove the stuff about voting, etc.

I am not 100% sure who to ask at the ECC, I know you are all busy but have provided really good feedback recently. so sorry for @ ing you @daira @str4d @nathan-at-least (why have @'s stopped auto completing)

Once we have past the 31st dead line, can we still take parts of one proposal and put it into another proposal? or is it “there can be only one”?

Thanks,
Steve

[sonya]

@mistfpga

Is a proposal meant to be all encompassing trying to cover everything in one go, or can/should we have a multitude of proposals that can work together and pick and chose from each parts.

Closer to all-encompassing. Each proposal should be cohesive and complete. It can still duplicate part of a different proposal, or be equivalent in some other way (although that should be referenced). It’s okay for proposals to overlap, but like a Venn diagram, not like two circles on top of each other. Does that make sense?

@mistfpga

with my proposals I would like to simplify them as much as possible and remove the stuff about voting, etc. […] Once we have past the 31st dead line, can we still take parts of one proposal and put it into another proposal? or is it “there can be only one”?

I’m not sure about this part.

[daira]

@mistfpga

Once we have past the 31st dead line, can we still take parts of one proposal and put it into another proposal?

Speaking in my role as ZIP Editor: yes. I’ll consult with @gtank (the other ZIP Editor) about how long we allow for that process.

@sonya

Each proposal should be cohesive and complete.

I think this may be too strict. There may be sound technical reasons to combine proposals, if there is community support for doing so.

[sonya]

^ Daira definitely overrules me when it comes to the ZIP process, so follow hir advice not mine

[mistfpga]

Hurm, just looked at zip0, I don’t ever remember seeing this in it before.

It is highly recommended that a single ZIP contain a single key proposal or new idea. The more focused the ZIP, the more successful it tends to be. If in doubt, split your ZIP into several well-focused ones.

But that is where I must have got the idea to do lots of little proposals. or just parallel thinking.