Future Dev and Legal Defense Fund ZIP

(Originally written for a wider audience of people less familiar with Zcash – i.e. twitter and bluesky.)

Tachyon Group (led by Sean Bowe) and Shielded Labs just posted a proposal to end future funding of the Zcash Community Grants program and reduce its treasury.

The Zcash community is going through a governance crisis. Sounds bad! Feels bad. Although it helps to remind myself that this has happened many times before—I’ve lost count—and things have always turned out okay before.

One of the flashpoints of the current disagreement has to do with the Zcash Community Grants program, which suddenly grown to have a *much* bigger amount of money and importance due to the price of ZEC rising.

For background, please see this post I wrote last June about ZCG’s finances and what changes we should consider: Should we change how we use the Dev Fund?

There are a number of proposals out there (Zcash Improvement Proposals—ZIPs) to defund the Zcash Community Grants program in various ways, along with posts attacking the legitimacy of the program.

However, the program was necessary to sustain and develop Zcash for many years, including funding the only working wallets for years, and the development of coin-holder voting, which is an important and still ongoing, evolution of our governance process.

Tachyon Group (led by Sean Bowe) and Shielded Labs just posted a proposal to reduce the treasury, end the flow of funding, preserve operational capacity, donate $50M to Network Sustainability, and create a Future Dev and Legal Defense Fund: zips/zips/draft-mcgee-future-dev-legal-defense-fund.md at future-dev-legal-defense-fund · aquietinvestor/zips · GitHub

Please support the Future Dev and Legal Defense Fund ZIP. If you’ve submitted an alternate proposal, even if yours is better than this one :-), please withdraw yours and support this one. Let’s all move forward together and make Money For An Infinite Civilization! :shield:

P.S. Shielded Labs does not take any money from the Zcash Community Grants program. We are funded solely by generous donations from Zcash holders and supporters.

Here’s Sean’s post: Sean Bowe on X: "The Future of ZCG in Zcash" / X

33 Likes

I fully support it if it preserves ZCG and its freedom, although I would have liked some restructuring, and a TWAP-based (similar to @ValarDragon 's idea) donations system so if the price goes down (which is EXACTLY when we need ZCG, exemplified by post-exploit prices in June), the ZCG can get back on its feet.

Further, what do you think about the ZCG having an arm in the US or Switzerland so it can fund studies, research and legal defense, as well as attract formal labs who don’t want ZEC?

4 Likes

Thanks for this alternative zooko! I have an honest question

Why doesnt the coinholders fund contribute to NSM too?

We currently have the protocol lockbox which could be donated either entirely or in full to the NSM from the coinholders side.

10 Likes

There is an irony I find in all this, though. We are now taking control of spending the money from ZCG on beneficial things now, and giving the control to partners at Kirkland & Ellis in the future who bill $2,000 an hour each for nothing but writing amicus briefs or debating. They will make sure to milk it thoroughly.

And we don’t even have a legal structure to defend at this point. Establish a defensible foundation for Zcash somewhere that’s not the Caymans.

1 Like

Speaking for myself, I mentioned earlier that we didn’t even have a way to put forward a proposal that would gain majority support:

Since it’s now clear that this proposal has the most support of all the options that have been put forward so far, I join the call to withdraw the previously submitted proposals and shake hands on this.

7 Likes

I support this proposal @zooko

However I’m concerned about the precedent it sets. If Zcash doubles or triples in price (which is not out of the question) will ZCG be pressured to continuously pair down its holdings?

12 Likes

That’s why a much better option is to stagger and hold instead. Hold all inputs into ZCG for a set period like between each coinholder vote, instead of cutting it off entirely. Then depending on Zcash’s price (TWAP) and ZCG’s need, its either given to ZCG or put in the “legal defense fund” (which, again, has nothing to defend)

2 Likes

There is no emergency.

Give the community 3 months to decide all this.

Any reallocation of ZCG’s funds is theft.

This proposal is from people backed by Tyler and Cameron Winklevoss.

The same people who pushed hard for the NSM.

8 Likes

Yeah, I don’t support any proposal to pause the funding stream to ZCG that doesn’t also pause the funding stream to coin voters.

2 Likes

I agree with @emersonian here.

I am attending Zcon, as are many other regular participants of this forum. It is actively disrespectful to existing and long-standing, well-respected Zcash stakeholders to act at the speed that this manufactured emergency is suggesting you need to.

I am personally extremely disappointed that three ZCG members did not attend Zcon. Human governance should happen at human-scale speed. We are not computers.

I strongly disapprove of not only the behavior of many members of this community but also the lack of consideration moving quickly and breaking HUMAN things prominent voices in this community are doing. It is tantamount to active exclusion.

Slow. The. Fuck. Down, y’all.

7 Likes

radbro

at law

Thank you for this collaboration @zooko. Like all middle of the road compromises, I don’t really like it, but I can tolerate it in the interest of moving forward.

Please note that this proposal lacks a USD cap on the total fund, and I can foresee this issue re-surfacing if ZEC appreciates rapidly again. The proposed amount staying in ZCG already makes me highly uncomfortable.

That said, I will withdraw my ZIP to wind down ZCG and support this one, if @ZCG commits to not pursue their plan to extend and expand ZCG and support this one.

2 Likes

And what if it depreciates?

3 Likes

The draft’s Rationale says the amount is “about 55% of ZCG’s ZEC” and that ZCG keeps the rest. That describes the number. It doesn’t derive it. Nothing in the ZIP says why 55% is right rather than 30% or 80%.

What has happened in the thread is textbook anchoring. A week ago the default was that ZCG keeps 100% of what it holds. Then “abolish ZCG, send everything to the NSM” went on the table. Now 45% kept reads as moderate, and a “middle of the road compromise”.

A midpoint between two positions isn’t a justification. That’s the argument to moderation. I’m not claiming anyone planned this sequence, but that is its effect, and we should notice it before voting on a number nobody has defended.

The draft’s own math hints at the real target: at $1,300 and $9.4M/yr, 50,000 ZEC leaves about 6.4 years of runway. But a fixed ZEC amount can’t encode a runway target. With the draft’s inputs, six years of runway means donating about 53,000 ZEC at $1,300, about 29,000 at $800, and nothing at $429, June’s price, where ZCG would still be 25,000 ZEC short. Same goal, anywhere from zero to 53,000. It’s a price bet taken at a local high, which is @strahncryptography 's “what if it depreciates?” question.

My position: end the stream, and ZCG keeps what it already holds. Apply the same rule to the coinholder fund: end its 12% stream too, and it keeps what it holds. There’s no reason one grants pot stops accumulating while the other keeps going. That is how the Ethereum Foundation works. Funded once, no issuance, and the pot managed under a published treasury policy in dollar terms rather than given away (EF policy). If the authors want either fund smaller, they should state the goal and derive the number from it. Then there’s something to debate.

(I work at zodl and these are my own opinions)

7 Likes

Exactly. And the funds MUST be converted to fiat, and restructured. This is how the Ethereum Foundation works.

Given the scale of funds and the fact that elections happen, I would suggest a custodian be a guardian of a trust with a defined document, a large, established entity such as JPMorgan. They can administer and verify elections by appointing trustees who are bound by fiduciary duty (read: legal principle as old as law itself that bounds a trustee to act in good faith, with insane penalties and criminal punishments under contract law for violations)

This ensures the fund is managed prudently, and allows us to give elected members ultimate power while still ensuring they can’t, and no offense, run away with the funds, while ensuring no other party bears control over it too.

Much like a smart contract, except this one is globally recognised, reputable, can’t be hacked, and is legally enforceable.

Then critics say “b-but muh decentralisation!” Zcash’s development is basically centred across 5 organisations, and now billionaires…

Yes, a consensus is definitely needed (which is always difficult among human beings).

I truly hope that the decisions currently being made aren’t aimed solely at protecting the interests of investors, miners, or coin holders—because they rely on communities to spread the word about Zcash, use it, promote it, and increase its visibility ALL ACROSS THE GLOBE.

Regional communities need funding. We all know how much a Zcon costs—the logistics, outreach, invitations, planning, and so on. Now, imagine that on a smaller scale, in every country and region where we organize meetups, workshops, gatherings, conferences, talks, etc. That also requires money! Cutting off that funding abruptly could be a very foolish decision.

I want to trust that this will work out.

5 Likes

Coinholders can always vote more funds to ZCG (from the coinholder grants lockbox) if it is deemed necessary to sustain Zcash.

What types of people and organizations would the legal defense fund support?

Would it support contributors that some coinholders disagree with?

It’s currently hard to believe that a defense fund would show up to support a ZECsy team member if they were prosecuted solely for promoting Zcash at a normal crypto conference, for example.

(I realize that the ZIP locks the funds for later decision, but my point is that those funds are available now quickly via a grant, and you’re locking them away. I highly doubt a ZIP to fund someone’s legal defense would get approved quickly given the recent debate climate around here)

3 Likes

Something I haven’t seen anyone consider: can ZCG legally direct its funds to the NSM? Per ZIP 1015 (which governs the ZCG funds):

FPF MUST disburse them for grants and expenses reasonably related to the administration of the ZCG program, but subject to the following additional constraints:

  1. These funds MUST be used exclusively for issuing Zcash Community Grants to external parties that are independent of the FPF or to Autonomous Entities operating under the FPF umbrella. Additionally, they MAY be used to cover expenses reasonably related to the administration of Zcash Community Grants.
...

FPF SHALL be contractually required to recognize the ZCG slice of the Dev Fund as a Restricted Fund donation under the above constraints (suitably formalized)

I presume that FPF fulfilled its obligation in 2024, which means there should be legalese that requires them to only use the ZCG funds in the prescribed way. A Legal Defense Fund is arguably within the terms of ZIP 1015 (it would be an external party); a donation to the NSM is not (it is not an external party, nor an Autonomous Entity operating under the FPF umbrella).

This ZIP draft clearly agrees with me, as it includes a modification to ZIP 1015 to permit an NSM donation. But that wouldn’t alter how the FPF has recognised existing received ZEC from the ZCG slice as a Restricted Fund donation under the constraints prior to this draft ZIP; it could only alter subsequent received ZEC.


Also, as an aside, has FPF been doing this other thing they were required to periodically do?

FPF SHALL conduct periodic reviews of the organizational structure, performance, and effectiveness of the ZCG program and committee, taking into consideration the input and recommendations of the ZCG Committee. As part of these periodic reviews, FPF MUST commit to exploring the possibility of transitioning ZCG into an independent organization if it is economically viable and it aligns with the interests of the Zcash ecosystem and prevailing community sentiment.

It is certainly economically viable for ZCG to be an independent organization now…

5 Likes

We asked FPF to review this before and they concluded it was possible and legal to do this. There are actually surprisingly few restrictions so long as the ZIP requirements are followed.

2 Likes