Introducing Zenzcash - the forum, minus the emotional whirlwind

Hi everyone! We’ve built Zenzcash for people who want to get caught up on the Zcash forum, but want to avoid reading long, heated threads which feels like being pulled into an emotional tug of war.

The idea is to make it easier to follow the substance of a disagreement without getting swept up in the tension.

A few things you can do:

  • Catch up quickly with AI-generated summaries of the key questions and disagreements.
  • Read less inflammatory versions of posts, with rewrites that aim to preserve the author’s meaning while taking the heat out of the language.
  • Listen to summaries or selected posts, with adjustable playback speed. Listen on your drive or while you’re cooking
  • Explore with your own AI: copy selected posts with a ready-made prompt for your AI. Ask questions, compare perspectives, or dig into the arguments.
  • Filter your reading by account age, tone (positive/negative), or quality of argument support.
  • Hide author names to focus on the ideas. (can attest this significantly changed what i took away from some posts!)

It’s an early release, and we’d love your feedback! If it helps you, please share it.

(And if you want to take this on to make it better, please also reach out!)

This idea grew out of small-group workshops at @ZcashFoundation’s Zcon in Cancún last week. Thanks to everyone in the workshop for helping shape it: @gustavovalverde @zancas @DearKane @AAmandita

Built by sudo_ml @sudo & Taylor @earthrise

13 Likes

The idea is really cool. As the feedbacks are open. I think the product design will be essential for this type of data, as it will a “detox” of the text to ensure better readability. But overrall, keep going, I want to use this.

2 Likes

the very idea of this >>>

It turned out amazing! I’m going to use it myself to better manage the flow of information. Thank you so much!

2 Likes

This is great. Catching up on long threads through summaries, without the heat, is exactly what I needed. I’ll be using it a lot. Nice work!

1 Like

I like this idea in theory but I worry that it will veer into “neutrality in the face of oppression empowers the oppressor” territory. It is correct to be heated and mad about some things, after all. I looked at this myself and I appreciate the summaries but this initial concern remained.

Ethical arguments are valuable on their ethical merit, too. They are stronger when their appeal to emotion is present because ethics are not about rationality, per se, they are about core values of right and wrong. In what ways does this tool allow such arguments to be delivered with their full weight or not?

1 Like

I want to understand this one better. Can you give some specific examples of what this feature changed for you?

I put this on X but I think a really interesting use case would be to take the forum interactions and use an algorithm like eigentrust to understand how people interact/support/disapprove of various topics. Would be a barometer of sorts on various topics and how they’re supported… you can approach it on a topic level (ie governance, consensus methods, etc…) and then understand how they interconnect and start to see personas/profiles of how folks here are thinking… just an interesting way to look at data and opinions in a different light

1 Like

This is great! I thought about doing something very similar, but it looks like you beat me to it :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:

1 Like

I am here for the long heated threads though :slight_smile:

1 Like

I would read something that sounds reasonable, but unmask the author to see the name of someone I think is often more unreasonable

On the flip side, I would read something that sounded wacky, and I unmask the author to see it’s someone I generally think is reasonable

In both cases, I realize that I was able to get more truth out of the post than I would have if my (natural) biases didn’t exist. It’s normal and natural for people to have preconceived notions - that’s how we avoid spending our lives making the same mistakes. But it certainly helps to have a tool that helps you judge individual statements on their own merit.

I understand the concept. I was asking for specific examples.

I will have to keep those opinions to myself! :wink:

1 Like

I like this idea, and will likely use this tool, but I am mindful that there’s information in “the heat”. Often someone is trying to express suffering.. or a need for help.. or a confusion..

So I won’t use this tool exclusively.

At least that’s my current prediction.

3 Likes

This is a real problem. I’ve bailed on threads before because the tone made it hard to tell what people were actually arguing about.

The part I’d want nailed down is the rewrite feature. Summaries are one thing. Changing someone’s wording is where trust gets thin. I’d suggest:

  • always show the original and the rewrite side by side, with a link to the exact post

  • label every generated summary and rewrite clearly, and keep the original one click away

  • let authors opt out of having their posts rewritten, or at least flag when a rewrite may have changed meaning

  • be explicit about where post text goes: local model or third party API, and whether it is stored or used for training

  • make tone and quality filters explainable. Account age is easy. “Quality of argument support” is not

Hiding names is interesting, but I’d keep it off by default. Context matters, and anonymous mode can make bad faith posting easier to miss.

Good luck with the early release. I’d rather see a small, transparent tool than a slick one that quietly paraphrases people.

1 Like

I should mention while I appreciate my new AI brotherin, I always value human to human comms a byte more. Hiding behind a shield has its place, but it isnt always the best tool.

1 Like